Skip to content

Katrina leaves a flood of haunting TV images

NEW YORK (AP) — As the week wore on, TV images were more and more chilling, even numbing, in their intensity.

In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, viewers faced scenes of roads turned to rivers, communities to lakes, buildings to rubble. They saw survivors cling to makeshift rafts. A man on crutches slogged through knee-deep water outside New Orleans’ Superdome. An almost biblical vision: water seemingly on fire, blazing from a broken gas line on a flooded street.

Cameras caught evacuees swarming around buses at the Superdome and greeted them on their arrival at Houston’s Astrodome.

Fox News Channel correspondent Jeff Goldblatt interrupted his dispatch to warn a man he saw filling a plastic jug from a fountain.

“Sir, that water isn’t clean,” he told the man.

The torrent of images recalled 9/11, except this stretched for miles. It recalled the Asian tsunami tragedy, except this was home, the victims our neighbors.

“Is there one image,” ABC’s Diane Sawyer asked President Bush during an interview at the White House Thursday morning, “that symbolizes to you the dimension of what happened?”

Without hesitation, Bush recalled the sight of “somebody sitting on a rooftop waving a flag, saying `Come and get me.'”

Other viewers were haunted by what CBS’ John Roberts called “a scene that would be shocking even in a Third World country”: a woman stranded on a New Orleans overpass whose “husband of 53 years died at her feet” and still lay there, shrouded in a blanket.

These were images that, in their scope and severity, didn’t look like the America most viewers recognize.

“It is clear that this disaster has changed this country,” said Brian Williams Wednesday night, bathed in light supplied by NBC’s own generator as he reported from a dark street in New Orleans’ French Quarter.

The disaster wasn’t limited to New Orleans, of course.

“Total devastation,” summed up ABC’s Terry Moran, standing amid ruins in Pass Christian, Miss. “There’s a stench of natural gas leaks and rotting garbage and who-knows-what-else in the air.”

It was clear a dreadful distance had been traveled since the week began, when TV news began setting the stage (or trying to) for Katrina’s wrath.

“We started right on the coast, right on the sand on a beautiful Sunday morning,” reported Fox News Channel’s Steve Harrigan the next day as he leaned into the fierce gale battering Gulfport, Miss. “We pulled back about five miles … I think we’re gonna be all right as far as the storm surge goes.”

But this spectacle of correspondents buffeted by wind and rain was only the prelude.

MSNBC’s Sean McLaughlin stood in a portable lift Monday morning and hoisted himself to the ceiling of the studio in Secaucus, N.J., to demonstrate how high Katrina’s wall of water might rise when it slammed the Gulf Coast.

But by week’s end, this exercise, like so many other previews, betrayed an all-too-understandable failure of imagination. It suggested surgically imposed devastation — a catastrophe apart from human miseries like death, disease, hunger and thirst.

And separation from loved ones. CNN introduced a “Victims and Relief Desk” service to help connect missing and stranded people with their families and friends. Who could have imagined such a need a week earlier?

After days of this, viewers might reasonably have felt overwhelmed.

At least one correspondent in the middle of it readily admitted he did.

“Even when you’re on the ground, it’s mind-numbing,” CNN correspondent John Zarrella told The Associated Press.

“There’s one horrific image after another. It comes at you from every direction,” he said Wednesday, just arrived in Baton Rouge after reporting from New Orleans since Saturday. “I don’t know how we can absorb the magnitude of this thing.”

This thing seemed to feed on itself.

Wednesday on Canal Street, MSNBC’s Michelle Hofland competed with rescue-truck sirens to describe how, all day, “looters have been going inside (that building). But just a few minutes ago, fire started billowing out of there.” Now other buildings were threatened.

Day after day, viewers have been flooded by video from intrepid camera crews, reporters with videophones, and citizen-journalists sharing footage and photos.

Even so, the unspeakable was sometimes best conveyed by spoken word.

On “NewsNight with Aaron Brown” Monday, they heard CNN’s Jeanne Meserve tell by phone what she had seen on a boat with a rescue team.

“It’s been horrible,” she began, and painted this picture: “As I left tonight, darkness, of course, had fallen. And you can hear people yelling for help. You can hear the dogs yelping, all of them stranded, all of them hoping someone will come.”

By week’s end, the picture of Katrina had only gotten worse.

Leave a Comment