Skip to content

Are dollars buying political favors in Tennessee?

CHATTANOOGA (AP) — Some lobbyists in Nashville are giving money to legislators and failing to report all the generosity, records show.

A Chattanooga Times Free Press analysis of campaign finance records shows 186 lobbyists reported contributing a total of $245,180 to legislative campaigns or political committees last year. Candidate and political committee records show lobbyists contributed a total of $554,576.

Leah Rush of the Center for Public Integrity, a Washington, D.C.-based watchdog group, said the discrepancy means Tennessee voters do not know if dollars are buying favors.

“There is no real reporting in Tennessee for lobbyists,” said Rush, executive director of the centers states project.

The newspaper compared lobbyists’ activity reports at the Tennessee Registry of Election Finance with an electronic database the registry keeps of campaign contributions that candidates and political committees receive.

The maximum fine for failing to disclose a contribution is $10,000. The penalty for failing to file a report is $750, said Drew Rawlins, executive director of the registry.

Rawlins said a lobbyist is in some ways better off not filing than filing a report that is false or contains mistakes.

“I think that speaks volumes for itself,” Rawlins said.

Records show there were 542 lobbyists registered in Tennessee in 2004. They represent business and industry, labor organizations, governmental agencies and other groups.

Dick Williams, director of Tennessee Common Cause, said the public is interested in the way contributions from special interests might influence how laws are made.

“The money they put in affects who’s elected, and it affects public policy,” he said.

Bob Swansbrough, a political science professor at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga, said there are “so many loopholes in the (disclosure) law that people are driving Mack trucks through it.”

The newspaper found that lobbyists failed to list on their disclosure forms at least $18,795 in contributions that candidates reported. The registry underreported $77,000 in contributions lobbyists disclosed to the agency, and state law allowed $213,601 to go unreported, records show.

The registry, an independent entity of state government that the General Assembly created in 1989, has a four-member staff with no authority to investigate violations independently and little authority to enforce fines.

Former Hamilton County school board member and independent lobbyist Charles Love, who pleaded guilty to giving bribes to state lawmakers as part of the FBI’s Operation Tennessee Waltz, had the most unreported contributions with four, records show.

John M. Farris, a Memphis-based lobbyist whose clients include Erlanger hospital in Chattanooga and Comcast cable services, did not disclose a $1,000 contribution to Lt. Gov. John Wilder or a $500 contribution to former state Sen. Larry Trail, documents show.

Farris said he did not have any record of contributing to Trail, but he said he did find a record of the check to Wilder and notified the registry.

“I’m sure if something has not been reported, it’s just a simple error,” Farris said. “There’s nothing clandestine going on.”

Gov. Phil Bredesen has appointed an advisory panel to recommend possible ethics law changes. The panel meets Thursday in Chattanooga.

A national study released recently by the Center for Public Integrity ranked Tennessee 45th for effectiveness of lobbyist-disclosure requirements.

———

Information from: Chattanooga Times Free Press, http://www.timesfreepress.com

Leave a Comment