Skip to content

North Carolina appears likely to remain lottery-free

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — After two decades of losing, it finally looked like supporters of a lottery in North Carolina had themselves a winner. But the lottery now looks like a sure thing that started strong and faded down the stretch.

A vote shy in the state Senate, supporters are coming up short against a coalition that has yet to back down. And so unless leaders can shake loose one more “yes” vote, North Carolina appears all but certain to remain the only state on the East Coast without a lottery for another year.

“I don’t know if they’re going to pass it or not,” Loyd Ferrell said while scratching off instant-win tickets recently at a convenience store in Bracey, Va., about 65 miles north of his home in Raleigh. “It’s just a chance. You never know when you might get lucky.”

Lottery supporters, after two decades of futility, thought this was the year their luck had turned. They won a House ballot in April by two votes, sending the lottery to the Senate, which had historically supported a numbers game and is home to the closest allies of Democratic Gov. Mike Easley, an ardent lottery supporter.

But then came weeks of negotiations over the state budget that diverted the attention of lawmakers. In the rush to wrap up business for the year after legislators finally agreed on a spending plan, all of the Senate’s 21 Republicans, along with five of the chamber’s majority Democrats, remained steadfast against the lottery.

Opponents hold a 26-24 advantage in the 50-seat chamber; unless a member of that majority switches their vote and creates a tie, sure to be broken in favor of the lottery by Democratic Lt. Gov. Beverly Perdue, Senate leaders are unlikely to call for a vote this coming week when the legislature is set to adjourn for the year.

“I don’t think the government should be advertising gambling,” said Democratic Sen. Janet Cowell, one of the so-called “Lottery Five” who were unswayed by meetings with Senate leaders and the pleas of public school teachers who say a lottery would generate more than $400 million annually for education. “I don’t think a lottery’s good public policy.”

So strong is the opposition that Democratic Sen. David Hoyle darkly joked at one point that the lottery’s only chance is if some senators can’t vote. “If there’s an ax murderer on the floor, we might be able to move forward,” he said.

Lawmakers have already decided where the state’s rake of lottery proceeds will go — school construction, college scholarships for low-income students, and Easley’s initiatives to reduce class sizes and prepare 4-year-olds for kindergarten. But they must first pass the separate legislation enacting the lottery before the money begins to stack up.

“The lottery seems to be the quickest and easiest way to raise money,” said Tammie Page, a fifth-grade teacher in Sampson County, who drove to Raleigh to track down Democratic Sen. Charlie Albertson, one of the holdouts.

Lottery bills have for years knocked around the General Assembly like the familiar pingpong balls of drawings in other states. The Senate has approved a lottery at least three times, only to have the idea die in the House.

The odds of a numbers game emerging in North Carolina got better in 2000, when Easley made passing a lottery a pillar of his first campaign for governor. It’s been a winning issue ever since; polls have repeatedly shown about two-thirds of North Carolina residents back a lottery.

But religious conservatives opposed to gambling have joined liberal advocates concerned about its social consequences. The polls don’t reflect that odd political dynamic, said Ferrel Guillory, who heads the program on Southern politics at the University of North Carolina.

“The polls say there’s a lot of public support for the lottery,” Guillory said. “But within the policymaking and opinion making, the lottery is opposed from both the right and the left.”

Pure politics are involved, too. The Senate’s Democratic leaders believe there are some lottery supporters among Republicans in the chamber. But the GOP, sensing a rare victory in the Democratic-controlled Legislature, has held together.

“The Republicans have locked all the members down,” said Senate Majority Leader Tony Rand.

The pressure on lawmakers has grown since South Carolina and Tennessee both started games, leaving North Carolina surrounded by lottery states. Lottery supporters say North Carolina residents spend $300 million annually on out-of-state games.

“We don’t expect to lose all of those sales, but we don’t have a lot of competition obviously there right now,” said Donna Van Cleave, interim director of the Virginia Lottery, which gets as much as 10 percent of its sales from North Carolina. South Carolina gets 12 percent of its sales from its northern neighbor.

Both the Senate and the House will return to Raleigh this coming week, although they’re not scheduled to do much more than tie up loose ends before formally adjourning. If there’s no vote then on a lottery, it’s a sure bet lawmakers will resume their debate next year.

“As long as the budget remains tight, and you’re going to get a pent-up demand for new school construction, that will keep the lottery debate alive,” Guillory said.

And until then, players from North Carolina will find a place to wager on a lottery’s bouncing balls.

At the Bracey Mini Mart on a recent Sunday, half of the cars parked outside the popular destination for lottery players from North Carolina had license plates from the Tar Heel state.

B.J. Jacobs, 21, of Rougemont, left the store in his souped-up pickup after spending $100 with the hopes of striking it rich.

“There’s a possibility the $100 becomes $100 million,” Jacobs said.

Leave a Comment