Skip to content

Judge: Confederate letters belong to South Carolina

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A judge has ruled that a collection of rare, Civil War-era letters belong to the state rather than the man who has had them in his family for generations.

The state sued after Charleston resident Thomas Willcox tried to auction off the letters. Willcox, who is a descendant of Confederate Gen. Evander Law, filed for bankruptcy soon after.

The collection includes more than 440 letters detailing life in South Carolina between 1861 and 1863.

Many letters are correspondence between generals or the Confederate government and South Carolina Govs. Francis Pickens and Milledge Bonham during the Civil War. Three are written by Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee.

Other letters are from residents asking for help defending their communities or for the return of their slaves, who were taken from plantations to help build fortifications. Some of the letters provide gory details on the realities of war.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge John E. Waites issued an order Monday stating that the letters deal with the official duties of the governor and therefore are public records.

A large portion of the letters relate to the governor’s military duties, Waites said in the ruling.

“These include information relating to military supplies and shortages, military preparations, the strength and condition of the military, documentation of troop movement, accounts and reports on results of certain battles, and use of funds for military purposes,” Waites wrote.

Other provisions enacted during the time period are mentioned in the letters, Waites said. In 1861, the governor was authorized to issue bonds or stock in the name of the state to continue the construction of the new Statehouse. One of the letters, dated June 7, 1861, from Gov. Pickens to the president of the Bank of South Carolina deals with work on the capitol and the sale of state stock, the judge wrote.

Many of the letters have markings on them consistent with the docketing system of the day.

“Such a docketing system appears to indicate an intent to preserve the document as relating to the public office,” Waites said.

State Attorney General Henry McMaster said it was important for the state to get the letters back because they represent “a unique historic and turbulent period in our country and state.”

“We must do all we can to preserve the rich history and proud heritage of our state,” McMaster said.

The letters will provide a link to the past for researchers, historians and students, said Rodger Stroup, director of the state Department of Archives and History.

“We owe a debt of gratitude to the Willcox family for preserving the documents all these years,” McMaster said.

Willcox’s attorney, Kenneth Krawcheck, said he had only learned of the ruling Tuesday and had not had time to examine it.

“We’re going to review it in detail and then determine if we need to file an appeal,” he said.

Leave a Comment