‘Justice Sunday II’ highlights division of Baptist organizations
The Aug. 14 event is second in a series of televised rallies on judicial matters hosted at powerful churches in the Southern Baptist Convention.
Sunday’s will be held at the massive Two Rivers Baptist Church in Nashville. The pastor there, the Rev. Jerry Sutton, was recently elected first vice president of the convention. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay of Texas, himself a Southern Baptist, will be the headline speaker.
And the first Justice Sunday in April was held at a church in Louisville, Kentucky, home of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.
Meanwhile, other Baptist groups denounce the event.
“We’re very interested in making sure that a large Baptist gathering doesn’t speak for all Baptists,” said Hollyn Hollman, general counsel for the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty. Religious freedom is best maintained when politics and religion are kept apart, she said.
Southern Baptists disagree.
“Separation of church and state was never intended to mean separation of religiously informed moral values from public policy,” said Barrett Duke, vice president of public policy and research for the convention’s Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission.
The Southern Baptist Convention was the result of a 19th Century split in the American Baptist church over the issue of slavery, with southerners supporting the right to continue the practice as other churches became abolitionist, said Bill J. Leonard, dean of the Wake Forest University Divinity School and author of 2003’s “Baptist Ways: A History.”
Those wounds healed over time, and Southern Baptists joined with other sects to form what is now in Baptist Joint Committee in 1936.
Then, growing conservatism in the 1980s and 1990s created another split. The southern convention left the organization to found the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission as its political voice.
The BJC now represents several Baptist groups, including the moderate American Baptist Churches USA and the predominantly black National Baptist Convention of America.
“We call it the ‘fundamentalist takeover.’ They call it the ‘conservative resurgence,'” Hollman said of the break.
Since then, a sharp divide has emerged. Conservative Southern Baptists “believe secularism is an unofficial established religion,” Leonard said. “They are always dissenting against secularism to claim a rightful place for Christians to practice their faith.”
On the other hand, Leonard said, the Baptist Joint Committee believe their Southern cousins “are looking to privilege their kind of religion with some kind of state support and are themselves looking to become an unofficial established state religion.”
“Those divisions are as deep in the 21st century as the divisions that founded the Southern Baptist Convention in the 19th century,” he said.
