News junkies offer ideas on how to reinvent ‘CBS Evening New’
CBS boss Leslie Moonves wants to reinvent the “CBS Evening News.” That’s no news. Nor is the fact that Dan Rather exited the anchor chair in March, with Bob Schieffer spelling him until the new format, entailing one or more new anchors, is introduced. But what shape will this new newscast take? No word yet. In the meantime, speculation rages: What would be the ideal makeover for the program, and for dinner-hour news shows in general? We asked a number of varied observers from the broadcasting world — all of them news junkies — to offer their suggestions. (Are you listening, Mr. Moonves?)
———
Brooke Gladstone, co-host of NPR’s “On the Media” from WNYC:
After the election, the East Coast media elites determined that, if they wanted to reach out and touch America, they should look West toward the heartland. But if I ruled CBS News, I would look further East, across the Atlantic to the BBC.
One reason why the lusted-after 18-34 demographic seems to have a growing preference for Jon Stewart over the big three anchors is because sometimes he actually says what he believes, openly acknowledging that the true is not reducible to a he-said, she-said proposition. That’s a fiction so strongly rooted in network news that merely by puncturing it, Stewart always gets a big laugh. But he has to be funny. He doesn’t have to be fair. That’s where the CBS nightly news could shine.
Imagine an hour (yes, an hour!) of reported pieces and newsmaker interviews in which hard questions were asked and hard facts acknowledged, an hour in which evasive answers triggered follow-up questions and leaders were treated not as royalty but as the public servants, the employees, they are. The BBC World Service “Newshour” offers a regular rotation of probing hosts. They may showboat a little, but they’re generally kept in check, and since the BBC persists in asking the questions the public wants answered, it retains the trust of a majority of Britons and news consumers worldwide, even when it errs, even when it’s embroiled in controversy. Transparency is good. Courage is better still. A powerful injection of both would be a steroid booster for CBS News.
———
Tavis Smiley, NPR talk show host:
I hesitate to compete with my fellow Hoosier David Letterman and his always brilliant top 10 list, but here are my top 10 suggestions for making network news better:
— Expand political stories to include opinions not just from the tired old Democrat vs. Republican sides of the aisle, but to give voice to younger, diverse and out-of-the-mainstream political activists. And, include more women.
— Hire college and high school students to submit pieces for the program; you can’t make news relevant to those of a new generation unless they’re part of the operation.
— Close each newscast with a commentary from various op-ed writers around the country. And not just the usual suspects; there are fine journalists at small local publications and college newspapers.
— Do a weekly montage of the best monologue jokes from late-night comedians. Cable networks already do this effectively; it could be a nice way to close out the Friday evening news.
— Quit being so proprietary. If another network gets a great scoop, give credit and show a clip of it. The audience is sophisticated enough to know that not everything happens just on one channel. Air it before they hit the remote and find it on their own.
— Offer more how-to advice. Americans are overwhelmed with everything from shopping around for better health care to figuring out how their new multifeature cell phone works. Help them.
— Take ads for the evening news from something other than drug companies! You wonder why your audience is older? Check out all the spots for Viagra and Metamucil! This is a total turnoff for 25-year-olds, which is why they’re playing video games at 6:30 instead of watching the news.
— Young men like sports, so throw them a bone. Spend a minute or two on the big sports story of the day or week. Alex Rodriguez gets 10 RBIs in one game — show a few clips and do a quick interview. It’s what young men are all talking about that day.
— The world is shrinking, yet Americans are often embarrassingly clueless about people and places around the globe. Take a cue from the BBC and show them events and issues beyond their own backyard.
— We live in the most multicultural, multiethnic, and multiracial America ever, but you wouldn’t know it from watching the evening news. Pay more, much more, attention to issues of concern to the millions of black, brown, and yellow citizens in all the red and blue states … hire more correspondents and commentators who look like them … and watch your ratings soar. And, oh, did I mention include more women?
———
Broadcast journalist, “Nick News” host and producer Linda Ellerbee:
“Nobody turns to those evening newscasts anymore to find out what just happened. I’ve got 24-hour cable news. I’ve got my laptop. But I think it would be wonderful to have an evening newscast that had spent the day adding conscious thought to what happened — to see the work of intelligent people who had taken time to digest the events of the day and were explaining them as much as reporting them. We need a newscast for the 21st century. Let’s not just keep changing the faces and the set.”
———
David Milch, creator-producer of HBO’s “Deadwood”:
“I notice a kind of self-important piety in the tone of evening newscasts that, as a viewer, I could learn to live without. I come away not feeling better informed, but feeling as if I ought to feel morally improved.”
———
Penn Jillette, comedian-magician and Showtime series co-host with Teller:
“We have this belief that what a newscaster should do is: take the news, digest it, make opinions, then conceal those opinions from us. But when you’re biased I can easily understand what the news is, providing you tell me your bias up front: `I hate George Bush, and here’s the news.’ ‘The war in Iraq is stupid, now here’s the latest on it.’ This seems like such an easy solution.”
———
Janeane Garofalo, actress-Air America Radio talk show host:
“The most interesting and compelling thing they could do is tell the truth. If they really spoke truth to power, and were actually watchdogs of government and industry, it would be fascinating. You say it wouldn’t get ratings? How would we know?”
