Crutchfield, Love plead innocent in Tennessee Waltz case
Crutchfield and four other current or former state lawmakers are accused of taking payoffs to support proposed legislation before the Tennessee General Assembly.
Defense lawyer William Farmer said he was trying to have Crutchfield’s indictment dismissed, arguing the charges should be handled in Nashville or Chattanooga, not in Memphis.
“We have an indictment which is nothing more than an allegation,” said Farmer of Nashville. “We’re looking forward to seeing what evidence they have.”
Crutchfield, a Chattanooga Democrat, said he was heading home to return to his law practice. He refused to discuss the charges.
“Tomorrow morning I’ll be in my office bright and early,” he said.
Love’s lawyer, Bryan Hoss of Chattanooga, described the July 5 trial date set by a U.S. Magistrate as unlikely to be met.
Love is charged in two separate indictments and, on paper at least, scheduled for trial before two different judges at the same time.
Hoss said lawyers for all of the accused will spend weeks reviewing the government’s evidence before deciding on their defense strategies.
“We expect the government to provide probably hundreds and hundreds of hours of tape-recorded conversations of some fashion, possibly videotape, possibly audio recordings,” he said.
Hoss acknowledged that Love talked with representatives of a fake company the FBI set up for it’s sting.
“I’m sure Charles Love was recorded on those tapes,” he said. “It would be kind of disingenuous for me to say otherwise.”
Love, a lobbyist and member of the Hamilton County Board of Education, is accused of passing along bribes to Crutchfield from undercover agents. Love also is accused in a separate indictment with handling bribes for Rep. Chris Newton of Cleveland.
Crutchfield and Love are accused of taking $12,000 from FBI agents pretending to work for a company called E-Cycle Management Inc. Crutchfield, 76, has been in the Senate more than 20 years, and before that was in the state House.
E-Cycle supposedly sought changes in Tennessee law to clear the way for buying used computers from state and local governments.
The two-count indictment against Crutchfield and Love says Love met with E-Cycle representatives last year and told them it would be easier to get the legislation they wanted if they had “gifts to bear.”
The indictment quotes Crutchfield as thanking an E-Cycle representative for “being my friend” after a payoff was made to Love.
While Love is accused of handling bribes for Crutchfield, the indictment charges the senator with personally accepting two envelopes containing $1,500 each.
Also indicted are Sen. Kathryn Bowers, D-Memphis; Newton, a Republican; and former Democratic senators John Ford and Roscoe Dixon, both of Memphis.
Barry Myers, a political associate of Dixon, is charged with passing along payoffs to Dixon and Bowers.
Bowers, Ford and Myers have pleaded innocent and also have July 5 trial dates. Dixon was scheduled for arraignment Thursday, while no plea date had been set for Newton.
Ford, a senator for 31 years, resigned following his indictment, while Dixon left the Senate early this year to become a top aide for Shelby County Mayor A C Wharton.
Wharton demanded and got Dixon’s resignation following the indictments.
