Skip to content

Conservative Advocate: Gang of 14 engineers shaky deal

Let no one suppose that the “deal” engineered by the “Gang of 14” (7 Republicans and 7 Democrats) in the Senate last week put to rest either of the related major disputes that have been roiling that distinguished body in recent weeks. The would-be peacemakers labored and brought forth a mouse.

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.) says “The constitutional option” (or “nuclear option,” if you prefer) “is still on the table.” Minority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) says the deal “took the nuclear option off the table. The nuclear option is gone for our lifetime.” As for filibustering judicial nominees, the Gang agreed, henceforth, that will happen only in “extraordinary” circumstances. Yet one of the Democrats, Sen. Richard Durbin of Illinois, has already declared that two of President Bush’s nominees “will not go forward,” which appears to mean that their nominations qualify as the sort of “extraordinary” circumstances that will trigger filibusters.

What’s left? The Democrats agreed to allow up-or-down votes on three nominees they had vociferously opposed (Priscilla Owen, Janice Rogers Brown and William Pryor), and it seems likely that the Senate will approve all three. The fate of all of the other nominees remains uncertain, pending a decision by the Democrats as to whether the designations of any of them were “extraordinary,” and thus qualify to be filibustered. If so, one or more of the seven Republican negotiators may decide to let the Democrats get away with this, and refuse to go along with Sen. Frist’s intention to invoke the constitutional option. One such defection might cause it to fail.

I personally would not bet a lot on the political future of any Republican who makes that choice because conservative Republicans, who dominate the party, are not likely to forgive it soon. (Sen. Lindsay Graham of North Carolina, and, perhaps, Sen. John Warner of Virginia are particularly at risk here.)

Sen. Frist would, of course, seek to invoke the constitutional option again, and this time his chances of success would be far greater. The Democrats having demonstrated, in the case of the Supreme Court nominee and any previous appellate court nominees who were filibustered to death, that they have no serious intention of limiting their filibusters, it should be easy to assemble 50 (out of 55) Republicans to overpower them.

The really important question is the complexion of the Supreme Court, which is almost sure to become an issue in the near future. For the remaining life of the 109th Congress — in other words, until January 2007 — the 55 Republicans who control the Senate can answer that question definitively. The Democrats are playing desperately for time, in the hope that thereafter the composition of the Senate may have changed, at least slightly, in their favor. It is up to the Republicans to move promptly, and decisively.

(William Rusher is a Distinguished Fellow of the Claremont Institute for the Study of Statesmanship and Political Philosophy.)

Leave a Comment