Skip to content

Upon Further Review: Home-school kids deserve chance to play

Getting an education is a right we all have as Americans. And quite simply it the most important thing a young man or woman can to ensure themselves of a better job and a brighter future.

In the past several months throughout the United States, a very serious question has been brought to the forefront of legislators and educators. And just recently this question has been brought to the attention of our state government and the TSSAA, who regulates over 5,500 high school and middle school teams in Tennessee.

The question is, should home-schooled students be allowed to play high school sports, and participate is such extracurricular activities as art, drama and music in public schools.

There are many pros and cons to both sides of this great debate and for the most part, I’ll have to side with the home-schooled parents.

Many argue that home-school families pay taxes to support public schools, but don’t get to take advantage of the activities they offer.

Now many of these kids already play sports in high schools, but it’s for Christian schools. Parents of these home-schooled athletes argue they want their kids to be able to play against better teams were the competition is much greater. Like the old saying goes, the better your competition is the better you become.

Already 14 states force public schools to allow home-schooled students access to classes and sports. Other states haven’t got involved in the debate and have opt to leave it at the discretion of the local school systems.

A similar proposal failed a few years ago in Tennessee, but with the number of home-schooled students growing this is far from over.

Now many people oppose this move and point out that families voluntarily choose to take their children out of public schools and away from those opportunities.

I’ve heard several reasons why they should not be allowed to participate, and some of them are just plain silly. They claim it will create headaches and will make eligibility requirements, such as minimum academic and behavior rules tougher to verify.

Well that might be so, but a little extra paper work and a few extra hours checking to see if home-schooled students are meeting all requirements should be worth the effort. After all these kids are our future and I’m sure there’s several home students out there that could help a lot of teams.

I can see were tracking could become an issue and maybe a few extra people would have to be hired to get out and do regular checks on the home-schooled athletes.

Some wonder how the home-schooled students would interact and mingle with public students. But I’m sure there would be no more that what goes on everyday in public schools.

If parents are willing to make every effort to follow all the rules and get their kids to all of the practices on time and do the extra work they will have to do, then I don’t see why the TSSAA and school officials can’t go the extra mile as well.

Like everything else in life you can’t please everyone, but in this case I think working together would benefit a lot of people.

Leave a Comment