Committee wants more discussion of covenant marriage bill
The bill was put off until next week for more discussion in the Domestic Relations Subcommittee.
Critics said establishing covenant marriages in Tennessee is unnecessary and could devalue regular marriages. Proponents of the bill said the extra commitment could make marriages stronger.
Sponsored by Rep. Glen Casada, R-College Grove, the proposed law is patterned after laws in Arizona, Arkansas and Louisiana. Those states have seen little impact from the law, with few people choosing covenant marriages and divorce rates staying about the same.
Under Casada’s bill, divorce from a covenant marriage could happen only in cases of physical or sexual abuse, adultery or abandonment for more than a year with one party refusing to return. If both parties decide to divorce, they must live apart but remain married for two years while undergoing counseling in an attempt to resolve differences.
Tennessee’s divorce rate is 5.1 per 1,000 population, which is tied with Florida for eighth-highest among 46 states and the District of Columbia, according to a 2002 analysis by the National Center for Health Statistics. The national rate is 4.0 per 1,000.
Rep. Tommie Brown, D-Chattanooga, complained that the legislation fails to spell out who would do the counseling to couples or other specifics.
“What are they going to do? Do they have to get a lawyer?” she asked.
Casada said the counseling requirements are adequately spelled out in the legislation.
Rep. Nathan Vaughn, D-Kingsport, questioned whether the bill was necessary since couples could already enter into a contract setting standards for their marriage.
Casada said that such contracts might be honored by one judge but not by another, while the proposed law would provide uniformity statewide. Vaughn said he considered himself completely committed by the pledge “until death do us part” in his current marriage.
“What you will do is devalue the existing marriage,” added Vaughn.
Couples that are already married could designate their marriage as a covenant marriage and file their declaration of intent, with a county court clerk holding their marriage certificate after the bill becomes law, which is Oct. 1 as drafted.
Rep. Mike Turner, D-Nashville, said he worries that younger people such as his 21-year-old daughter are too immature to take the extra step of a covenant marriage. He suggested a minimum age of 30.
Turner also said that citizens need to accept marriage for what it is without trying to change it through legislation.
“There ain’t no covenant jobs or benefits — I’d vote for that if we could,” he said. “But that’s not the way life is.”
Rep. Matthew Hill, R-Jonesborough, said a covenant marriage would be “totally voluntary” and the legislation does not interfere, since it “deals with how you get out of a marriage, not how you get into a marriage.”
Tuesday’s session had been scheduled as the last meeting this year for the Domestic Relations Subcommittee, but Chairman Sherry Jones, D-Nashville, indicated she would schedule another meeting next week to further consider the bill.
