Skip to content

Tennessee man faces death penalty:Though serious doubts about his guilt remain

Tennessee man faces death penalty:Though serious doubts about his guilt remain

Paul Gregory House, seen March 3, 2005, waits on Tennessee’s death row suffering from advanced multiple sclerosis at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville, Tenn., with no faith in his appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. (AP Photo)
NASHVILLE (AP) — Paul Gregory House waits on Tennessee’s death row, smoking cigarettes and watching TV from his wheelchair in the prison clinic, with no faith in his appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

“I really don’t care if they want to hear (my story) or not,” said House, who is 43 and has advanced multiple sclerosis. “I have no confidence that they’ll do anything about it.”

House was convicted of raping and killing his neighbor, Carolyn Muncey, 20 years ago, but his lawyers have raised serious questions that suggest he could be innocent.

After the conviction, DNA evidence later proved House didn’t rape Muncey, taking away the prosecution’s motive for the killing. A medical examiner has said the blood stains on House’s clothing may have been planted. And neighbors say Muncey’s abusive, alcoholic husband confessed to the crime.

That’s enough to create serious doubt in the minds of seven federal appellate court judges.

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati upheld House’s conviction and death sentence by an 8-7 margin last year. Six judges concluded House was innocent and the seventh said there should be a new trial.

“I am convinced we are faced with a real-life murder mystery, an authentic ‘who-done-it’ where the wrong man may be executed,” Judge Ronald Lee Gilman wrote in his dissent. “Was Carolyn Muncey killed by her down-the-road neighbor Paul House, or by her husband Hubert Muncey?”

But the majority says House raised questions but failed to prove “that it’s more likely than not that no reasonable juror would have convicted him in the light of the new evidence.”

“Despite his best efforts, the case against House remains strong,” Judge Alan E. Norris wrote for the majority.

Muncey’s battered body was found July 14, 1985, partially concealed at the bottom of an embankment near her rural home in Luttrell, about 25 miles northeast of Knoxville. A friend of Muncey’s husband said he saw House emerging from the area where the body was found.

An autopsy said a violent blow to the head caused Muncey’s death, and there were wounds to suggest she struggled with her attacker.

“I didn’t kill her,” House said in a recent interview with The Associated Press. “I haven’t studied law books and all that crap. I’m not that interested in the law, not after I’ve been burned by it. I couldn’t care less.”

House’s public defender, Stephen Kissinger, said his client is an innocent man, wasting away on death row.

“You’re talking about a man who has clearly lost hope, and not without reason,” Kissinger said. “Mr. House first tried to present this line of evidence back in state court 15, 16, 17 years ago.”

Kissinger expects the Supreme Court to rule on his petition sometime this year.

The Death Penalty Information Center said 119 people have been exonerated on death row since 1973 and 44 since 1999, but none from Tennessee. There are about 3,400 people on death row nationwide.

“Death sentences are down, executions are down, public support is down and I think DNA has played a big part of that,” said DIPC executive director Richard Dieter.

Beyond the DNA evidence that proved House’s semen was not found on Muncey’s night gown, more questions surfaced during a 1999 habeas hearing in federal court.

Neighbors of the Munceys — Penny Letner and her sister, Kathy Parker — testified that Muncey’s husband, Hubert “Little Hube” Muncey Jr., confessed to killing his wife. Parker also said Little Hube regularly beat his wife.

“He said they had been into an argument and he slapped her and she fell and hit her head and it killed her and he didn’t mean for it to happen,” Parker said.

The other physical evidence tying House to the crime — Muncey’s blood stains on a pair of his jeans — was challenged at the hearing by Assistant State Chief Medical Examiner Cleland Blake. He testified that the blood likely came from four test tube samples collected during Muncey’s autopsy.

For Judge Gilbert S. Merritt, that was “strong evidence that the sample in the vials of blood were mishandled or possibly even tampered with and intentionally spilled on the jeans” between the time it was collected in Union County and sent to the FBI crime lab.

Tennessee Attorney General Paul Summers has declined to comment on the case, but Paul Phillips, who prosecuted the original case in rural Union County, Tenn., said he’s “personally satisfied” the true killer is on death row.

“I have no doubt in my mind,” he said.

Even though House’s semen wasn’t on Muncey’s gown as originally contended at trial, Phillips said he never gave it the weight it has received in post-conviction proceedings.

“We know the semen stain on the night gown wasn’t his,” he said. “Would that have made a difference with the jury? I don’t think so. We never emphasized the semen stain. We proved that she fought her attacker, and she had a lot of injuries consistent with being strangled and being hit in the head.”

House admits he lied to investigators about his whereabouts on the night of the murder, and he had scratches and bruises on his hands and arms. He also had a prior conviction in Utah as a sex offender.

The prosecution said House lured Muncey out of her house the night she was killed by telling her that Little Hube had been in a car wreck.

“That was an entirely believable scenario,” Phillips said. “He was drinking bad at the time, and I’m sure she expected the damn fool to wreck.”

House, who had left his girlfriend’s house for a short walk on the night Muncey was killed, returned there a beaten mess. Phillips says it was from the struggle when he fatally beat her.

But House says he was attacked by two men who pulled up in a car.

“I may have known the second guy that got out of the passenger’s side. It might have been Little Hube, I really don’t know,” House said. “I never saw their faces. I mean, it was dark as hell that night.”

For at least one judge, the evidence is simply not clear.

“The evidence at House’s state-court trial clearly pointed to him as the perpetrator,” Gilman said. “But the evidence at House’s habeas corpus hearing before the district court just as clearly pointed to Hubert Muncey as the guilty party …

“At the end of the day, I am in grave doubt as to which of the above two suspects murdered Carolyn Muncey. I am also puzzled as to why more of my colleagues are not similarly in doubt.”

House, who wore a cigarette-burned white T-shirt during the interview and spoke haltingly, believes his situation is hopeless. He thinks the only way he will leave prison is after the state executes him.

“They just want to kill me, whether they’ve got anything against me or not,” he said.

Leave a Comment