Federal appeals court upholds Tennessee optometrists law
National retailers LensCrafters, U.S. Vision, Cole Vision Corp. and trade association, the National Association of Optometrists and Opticians, had earlier unsuccessfully challenged the 1967 Tennessee law in U.S. District Court in Nashville.
LensCrafters and the other plaintiffs have claimed since first filing suit in 1998 that the state law discriminates against optical retailers based outside Tennessee, because it allows optometrists in the state to sell eyewear in their offices. The plaintiffs contend lawmakers intended the law to help Tennessee optometrists by restricting interstate commerce.
The three retail plaintiffs operate businesses with optometrists on site, offering eye exams, eyewear, contact lenses and other products in one place.
Attorneys for the state have argued the law’s intention was to prevent optometrists, who are considered health care providers, from being under the control of retail optical store operators.
In 2003, U.S. District Court Judge Aleta Trauger ruled the law was not discriminatory and affected both Tennessee-based and out-of-state optical retailers equally.
The U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday affirmed Trauger’s ruling.
The appeals court decision also states that the law affects both in-state and out-of-state retailers equally. Judges also wrote that the plaintiffs did not prove that the intent of lawmakers was to give Tennessee optometrists and unfair advantage.
Both LensCrafters and Cole Vision are part of Luxxotica Group, based in Italy. New Jersey-based U.S. Vision operates optical departments in department stores.
