Supreme Court is taking away religious freedoms
Like the very air we breathe, most Americans take religious freedom for granted — until, of course, someone starts to cut off our supply.
That’s exactly what has happened over the past 15 years. With little outcry from the public, the U.S. Supreme Court has handed down rulings that many legal scholars believe have largely erased long-standing protections for the free exercise of religion.
How have these cases gone largely unnoticed in a nation where so many people say they take religion seriously — and where so many are pressing for religious symbols in the public square?
Let’s start with the fact that most of the religious-liberty cases decided by the Supreme Court involve minority religious groups that most people don’t understand (or don’t like). Most people in majority or mainstream religions don’t pay much attention to free-exercise cases – until some law or regulation strikes close to home. Then they are first in line to invoke the First Amendment. When zoning laws, for example, are used to prevent church construction or expansion, some of the largest religious groups quickly re-discover the free-exercise clause. But if you care about religious liberty, the free-exercise cases are the ones to watch.
To understand what’s at stake we need to return briefly to 1990 when the Supreme Court’s ruling in Employment Division v. Smith greatly reduced protections for free exercise of religion. In Smith, two Native Americans were denied unemployment benefits by the state of Oregon because they were fired for using peyote in their worship. Under a test used by the Supreme Court for decades before Smith, Oregon would have been required to show a “compelling state interest” in denying Native Americans a religious exemption from the anti-drug laws.
But in deciding the Oregon case, the Court changed the test. No longer would the government have to show a compelling state interest before denying a request for accommodation regarding a law that applied to everybody (as long as the law didn’t target religion). In other words, as long as Oregon bans peyote use for everyone — not just Native Americans — the state doesn’t have to grant or even consider an exemption for religious use.
Since most readers probably don’t need a religious exemption for drug use, let’s look at another scenario. Nathan Diament of the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations offers this stark example: “If a state outlawed all alcohol consumption for those under age 21 and made no exceptions for wine at Mass or Sabbath, a devout Catholic or Jew could not succeed in challenging that lack of exception as infringing on their Free Exercise rights.”
Not to be outdone, Congress (supported by a broad coalition of religious and civil liberties groups) tried again with another law in 2000 — the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act with the unpronounceable acronym RLUIPA — narrowly targeted to apply the compelling-interest test to zoning laws and the rights of prisoners and other institutionalized people. The Ohio prisoners in the Cutter case invoked RLUIPA, arguing that prison officials had no compelling reason (such as safety or discipline) to deny them access to religious literature and the opportunity to conduct worship services.
Last year, the 6th Circuit ruled that RLUIPA violates the establishment clause because “by enacting RLUIPA, Congress itself has advanced religion by giving religious prisoners a preferred status in the prison community.”
If the Supreme Court upholds the 6th Circuit and strikes down RLUIPA, many other laws passed by all levels of government to accommodate religious practice could be invalidated under the establishment clause. In other words, laws designed to protect religious freedom could be struck down as violations of the First Amendment – a strange twist that would render the free-exercise clause almost meaningless.
Do you enjoy breathing the sweet air of religious freedom in America? Then inhale deeply — while you still can.
Charles C. Haynes is senior scholar at the First Amendment Center, 1101 Wilson Blvd., Arlington, Va. 22209. Web: www.firstamendmentcenter.org. E-mail: [email protected].
