Skip to content

State rep: Federal judge playing game of chicken with TennCare

NASHVILLE (AP) — A state lawmaker says he thinks a federal judge has overstepped his authority with TennCare and might as well kick Gov. Phil Bredesen out of office while he’s at it.

U.S. District Judge William J. Haynes ruled Friday in a seven-page decision that Bredesen cannot reform TennCare by removing 323,000 TennCare enrollees from the state’s expanded Medicaid program.

“What this federal judge is doing is playing a game of chicken,” said Rep. Chris Clem, R-Lookout Mountain. “This federal judge ought to just kick the governor out of the governor’s mansion and move in.”

Haynes said he’ll hold hearings to see whether the state has exhausted all options to rein in costs for TennCare. He presides over a 1998 class action lawsuit against the state challenging TennCare’s eligibility screening for uninsured and disabled patients.

The state plans an immediate appeal of Haynes’ decision to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Haynes’ decision comes days before the governor is expected to release his budget for the coming year — a budget that relied on saving hundreds of millions of dollars in TennCare.

A status conference on the case is scheduled for Tuesday, while Haynes has set a hearing for Friday.

Haynes’ ruling was good news to those people due to be cut from the TennCare rolls.

“I’m amazed,” enrollee Ray Lewis said. “I was just beginning to get nervous and just wondering what we were going to do next.”

TennCare, left unchecked, is expected to eat up roughly $650 million in new state money next year. Bredesen said his cuts, which also included limits on benefits, were needed to keep the $8.7 billion program from bankrupting the state.

Haynes’ ruling came as some 40 elected officials, TennCare patients and social service workers met in Memphis to discuss the TennCare changes at a meeting organized by Memphis Area Legal Services.

Jimmie Harder Fowler told her own story of how she became the first person to undergo a liver transplant at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center nearly 22 years ago, then raised her family and built a successful real estate career.

Fowler has relied on TennCare since 1994 because she couldn’t buy private health insurance, and now her liver is failing. Doctors told her she may now need another transplant about the same time she learned she likely will lose TennCare coverage if Bredesen’s changes are approved.

“I’ve been trying to keep it together. Everything had been going so well. This kind of blindsided me,” she told Rep. Kathryn Bowers, D-Memphis and chairman of the TennCare Oversight Committee.

Bowers encouraged TennCare patients with questions to write the governor, and Rep. Mike Kernell, D-Memphis, said residents should write and call their state and local representatives.

“Go home and tell your story to your legislator,” Kernell told Fowler.

Leave a Comment