Skip to content

State Supreme Court limits when civil court records can be sealed

NASHVILLE — Open records advocates got a victory Thursday when the state Supreme Court issued guidelines that limit when judges should rule civil court documents be kept confidential.

The court’s rule says that it is “the public policy of this state that the public interests are best served by open courts and an independent judiciary.”

It spells out that court records are “presumed” to be open to the public and may be sealed only in limited circumstances, specifically documents filed privately with a court solely for the purpose of obtaining a ruling on the discoverability of such documents; court files to which access is restricted by law; and matters subject to a protective order or to maintain the privacy of financial information of individuals or closely held entities such as private partnerships.

“While most of these are technical changes, the adoption of new Rule 1A of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure is a significant change,” Chief Justice Frank Drowota said in a statement. “Prior to the adoption of this rule, there were no written guidelines for judges to use in deciding whether or not to seal, or close, certain court records.”

The court will now submit the rule to the Legislature for approval. If passed, it will become effective in July.

A number of cases over the past few years have drawn attention to the issue of open records. Most recently was the sealing of nearly all court records in lawsuits over a Nashville nursing home fire two years ago that killed 16 people.

In sealing the documents, Davidson County Circuit Judge Barbara Haynes said she believes in the public’s right to know and seals documents only when there are important reasons for doing so. In the nursing home case, she said, the files were sealed at the request of the plaintiffs and defendants.

Frank Gibson, executive director of the Tennessee Coalition for Open Government and a part-time editor at The Tennessean, said the Supreme Court rule would have made it more difficult for those records to be sealed.

“This is a giant step in the right direction to making affairs of state courts more public,” Gibson said. “Under this one (rule), the public has a right to object to any proposal to seal and to be heard on the subject, whether a party to the lawsuit or not.”

Blair Durham, who represented plaintiffs in the nursing home case, said he “personally supports the motion to have records open” and agrees with Gibson.

“Under the new rule, it would be hard for me to imagine that the NHC court records would be sealed,” Durham said.

The rule also applies to settlement agreements not filed in court but pertaining to a filed civil case, if the agreement restricts the disclosure of “information concerning matters that have a probable adverse effect upon the general public health or safety, or the administration of public office, or the operation of government.” The monetary amount of settlements may be kept confidential, however.

Richard Hollow, general counsel to the Tennessee Press Association, said he’s pleased with the court’s action.

“The Supreme Court should be commended for taking a very strong and affirmative stand with respect to the public’s right to know,” said Hollow, who helped draft Tennessee’s Sunshine Law, which requires governmental bodies — with the exception of the state Legislature — to hold open public meetings and announce them in advance.

“The court did the right thing. It needed to be done.”

———

On the Net:
Tennessee Supreme Court: http://www.tsc.state.tn.us.

Leave a Comment