Former officer’s lawsuit against city thrown out
|
“There were no grounds for the lawsuit to begin with,” said Mayor Royce Davenport following dismissal of the suit filed this September by Michael William Hainey, who was terminated after serving almost two years as a patrolman.
Hainey, presently a deputy in Cannon County, filed the suit asking the court to require the immediate resignations of McMinnville Mayor Royce Davenport, City Administrator Herb Llewellyn and Police Chief Joe Melton. He also asked for $25,000 in damages, along with lost earnings, and punitive damages. He also wanted the city to re-hire him so he can resign with dignity.
Hainey, who was cited for bravery for pulling a child from a burning apartment, maintained city officials were “drunk with power” and had “trampled the liberties” of their employees. Hainey contended he was fired because of an arrest he made and his subsequent recording of grand jury proceedings.
The recording was not against the law but such practices are highly discouraged during the meetings of the secret tribunal.
Hainey said he believes the city is abusing its “at-will” employment code and is discriminating against employees. The at-will employment code is used across the state and says an employer can terminate an employee at any time without reason.
However, Mayor Davenport took exception of Hainey’s allegation, saying he does not feel any city department has abused the system.
“We’re not going to abuse the at-will system and terminate someone just because they are not liked,” Davenport said. “As far as I know, since I’ve been mayor, no one has been let go other than people who did not perform their duties or jobs were there was a lack of work to justify continuing the position.”
“We try to be careful in our hiring, so we don’t get in a situation where we have to terminate someone,” Davenport added. “While we generally don’t give a reason, since this is an at-will state, we do keep documentation to back it up should there be a lawsuit.”
Hainey, who did not respond to the city’s motion for summary judgment thereby sealing the case’s doom, said he could not justify spending the time it was taking to get the case ready for trial, seeing as he was representing himself. Hainey added he was preparing paperwork for the case while at the same time balancing his job and family life.
“Hopefully this has at least raised awareness about how the city treats its employees,” Hainey said. “I’m not intimated by anyone down there.”
