Sweet Land of Liberty: Are FBI agents going too far?
Director Robert Mueller’s “new” FBI is lapsing into J. Edgar Hoover’s formerly discredited doctrine that certain types of nonviolent, anti-government protestors must not only be surveilled and their groups infiltrated, but also visited by FBI agents to chill their speech and other activities. In hearing about these intimidating FBI visits around the country before both the Democratic and Republic conventions, I’m reminded about government intimidation during the dissenting 1950s and counterculture 1960s.
Back then, FBI agents came to see me, demanding the sources for my criticisms of the bureau. Knowing my First Amendment rights, I politely sent them away. They did not return.
These days, however, FBI agents before both last July’s Democratic and this week’s Republican conventions — with particular zeal, as described in an Aug. 19 Denver Post editorial — “have gone about their mission aggressively, with little regard for basic rights and without evidence that the people they are trying to dissuade are actually intending any criminal activity.”
An Aug. 19 report in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch tells of “three men from Kirksville, Mo., (who) were so unnerved at being followed by agents and called to a grand jury here last month that they abandoned plans for peaceful protest outside the Democratic National Convention in Boston.” They now refuse to have their identities disclosed.
Denise Lieberman, the American Civil Liberties Union legal director for eastern Missouri, told me that the subpoenas required the three men to appear on July 29 – the very date they had planned to be in Boston before they decided not to go. After they appeared before the grand jury for about five minutes, no charges were filed.
The FBI, says Lieberman, had asked them if they had knowledge of anyone planning “criminally disorderly conduct” at the Democratic or Republican convention, presidential debates or other places. “The fact that they did not answer the questions,” Lieberman told the Post-Dispatch, “may have raised the red flag and gotten them the subpoena.”
Because of the appallingly low level of educational instruction about the history of our Constitution, including the Bill of Rights, in school systems around the country, it’s likely that these protestors didn’t know they had a First Amendment right not to answer the agents’ questions before they were subpoenaed.
Now, adds Lieberman, “they’re quite shaken and terrified by the experience. They’re concerned if they speak out, they’re going to be targeted further.”
In Kansas City, the Associated Press reported on Aug. 19, 21-year-old Nate Hoffman, a University of Missouri-Kansas City student, was approached by FBI agents at a coffeehouse. They asked whether he or anybody he knew planned to engage in violence at the Democratic conventions in Boston. Hoffman knew enough about the Constitution to refuse to answer without a lawyer.
“They told me,” says Hoffman, “that in their experience that when somebody didn’t want to talk to them that meant they probably had something to hide.”
During the presidential debates, will anyone ask the candidates about these visits commemorating the reign of J. Edgar Hoover? On Aug. 20, John Ashcroft, not surprisingly, told The New York Times, that any “suggestions that the interviews were aimed at stifling protests were an ‘outrageous distortion.'” Would James Madison agree?
Nat Hentoff is a nationally renowned authority on the First Amendment and the Bill of Rights.
