Skip to content

State appeals court to hear arguments on child porn law

KNOXVILLE (AP) — The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals will hear arguments in a Knox County case challenging the constitutionality of parts of a 1990 law that targets child pornography.

It will be the first time Tennessee’s appellate court has reviewed the state law since the U.S. Supreme Court struck down two major sections of a federal child pornography law in 2002.

The law at issue has two sections — one that bans the use of minors in pornography, the other that bans pornographic material that appears to show minors even if there is no proof the participants are under age. The court will hear arguments of the law as it is applied to child pornography distributed or received over the Internet.

“This is the first time that issue has gone up (for appellate review),” said attorney Gregory P. Isaacs, who will make the argument on behalf of one of three clients accused in Internet child pornography cases in Knox County Criminal Court.

“I’m pleased that the issue of the Internet and fundamental Constitutional principles will be resolved by a higher court,” Isaacs said Tuesday.

In November, Criminal Court Judge Richard Baumgartner ruled part of the law is unconstitutional because it allows a jury to decide if a person shown in pornography is a minor. He said that could lead to the conviction of a person for possessing pornography “even when an actual minor is not used.”

He declined to strike down the entire law.

Knox County Assistant District Attorney General Kevin Allen, who leads a state task force aimed at child pornography distributed over the Internet, was ordered by Baumgartner to turn over to defense attorneys a mirror image of a defendant’s computer hard drive and any printed images to be used as evidence. That effectively overruled Allen’s argument that the evidence was “contraband.”

The legal argument concerning both issues has stalled cases in all three of Knox County’s criminal court divisions, prompting Baumgartner to allow both sides to seek an appellate court review.

Appellate court judges James Curwood Witt Jr., Gary R. Wade and Joseph M. Tipton agreed last week to hear both appeals. A court date for arguments has not been scheduled.

There are more than two dozen Internet child porn cases pending in Knox County courts. Isaacs has joined other attorneys, including Robert R. Kurtz, James A.H. Bell and John Eldridge, in a bid to prove the law under which these cases are lodged is flawed.

Allen has waged his own battle, struggling not to turn over evidence of child porn to defense attorneys by arguing that doing so would make him a purveyor of obscene material.

The appellate court also will hear arguments on Allen’s contention defense attorneys should only be allowed to view evidence in child pornography cases under the supervision of task force members.

“Certainly, I’m glad they’ve agreed to hear it,” Allen said.

———

Information from: The Knoxville News Sentinel, http://www.knoxnews.com

Leave a Comment