Skip to content

Appeals court rules S.C. ‘Choose Life’ plates unconstitutional

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A federal appeals court has upheld a ruling that South Carolina’s anti-abortion license plates are unconstitutional.

A three-judge panel of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va., unanimously ruled Monday that the plates, which bear the slogan “Choose Life” violate the First Amendment by giving anti-abortion advocates a forum to express their beliefs without giving abortion rights supporters a similar forum.

“By limiting access to a specialty license plate to those who agree with its pro-life position, the State has distorted the forum in favor of its own viewpoint,” the court wrote. “South Carolina has engaged in viewpoint discrimination by allowing only the Choose Life plate.”

The ruling, which upholds a federal judge’s December ruling, is at odds with one by the New Orleans-based 5th Circuit Court of Appeals. That court ruled in December 2002 that Louisiana abortion rights advocates had no standing to sue that state over its anti-abortion plate.

The state plans to appeal Monday’s ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court, Attorney General Henry McMaster said.

The U.S. Supreme Court in December refused to hear the Louisiana case and it’s difficult to predict whether justices will hear the South Carolina case, McMaster said.

Columbia attorney Peter Murphy, who represented Planned Parenthood and Charleston resident Renee Carter, was not surprised by the appeals court ruling.

“We thought we were right all along,” said Peter Murphy, a Columbia attorney representing Planned Parenthood and another plaintiff. “We were right because the state violated the First Amendment when they created a forum to express opinions but limited access to the forum to only one opinion.”

South Carolina specialty license plates are approved in two ways. Either a nonprofit group can apply to have a plate whose sale will be restricted to its members, or the Legislature can approve a special plate on its own.

McMaster said Monday that Planned Parenthood and others were not discriminated against because it never applied for an organizational plate.

But the court wrote that a Planned Parenthood plate would at best allow certified members of the organization — not those with “pro-choice” views — to display a plate bearing the name of an organization.

“With all due respect to the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, the logic in this opinion is ridiculous,” McMaster said. “The court is trying to read the fine print of the constitution…and is getting lost in its own reasoning.”

McMaster noted that there are several license plates bear specialty slogans, including “United We Stand” and “In God We Trust.”

The law allowing the “Choose Life” plate was signed by Gov. Jim Hodges in 2001 and included in a bill that allowed NASCAR and other specialty plates. Last year, U.S. District Judge Patrick Michael Duffy issued a preliminary injunction blocking South Carolina from issuing the plates until the case was heard.

McMaster said the plate would be popular if it is approved.

“There would be a lot of people who would order the plate if it were available. I know there’s enormous support for the pro-life position in this state,” he said.

Leave a Comment