Supreme Court revisits claim of porn censorship
WASHINGTON (AP) — Online pornography has been around almost as long as the Internet itself, but Congress and the courts are still tangling over ways to protect Web-surfing children from smut that adults can legally see and buy.
The Supreme Court takes its third crack at the difficult issue Tuesday, as justices look at the free-speech ramifications of Congress’ latest attempt to require antipornography safeguards.
The justices struck down the first version of a child-protection law passed in 1996, during the Clinton administration, and refused to sign off on a replacement law passed two years later. That law has never taken effect, and is now before the justices for a second time.
“There is a compelling government interest in protecting minors from the effects of material that is not obscene by adult standards but that is nonetheless harmful to minors,” the Bush administration’s top Supreme Court lawyer argued in a court filing. “The Web poses a serious threat to that compelling interest.”
Free pornography is easy to find online, placed there as a hook to lure paying customers, the Bush administration and its backers argue. Minors can find that free material as easily as adults, although it would be illegal for a store owner to sell them a paper copy of a magazine that shows the same images.
“Minors today can search the Web as easily as they can change television channels,” Solicitor General Theodore Olson wrote. “Thus, in the seclusion of their homes or those of friends, unsupervised minors can, with the click of a mouse, visit one pornographic site after another.”
Kids can print those free teasers without paying to enter adult sites, Olson wrote.
Many porn sites try to limit access to adults, with varying success.
The 1998 Child Online Protection Act would make it a crime for commercial Web sites to knowingly place material that is “harmful to minors” within their unrestricted reach.
COPA could mean six months in jail and $50,000 in fines for first-time violators and additional fines for repeat offenders. It is on hold pending court challenges.
The American Civil Liberties Union claims the law violates the First Amendment guarantee of free speech. The ACLU challenged the law on behalf of online bookstores, artists and others, including operators of Web sites that offer explicit how-to sex advice or health information.
The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals first ruled the law unconstitutional on grounds that it allowed Internet content to be judged by “contemporary community standards.” Given the widespread availability of the Internet, the appellate court said, the law would force every site to abide by the most restrictive community’s standards.
In its first look at COPA, the Supreme Court delivered a partial victory to the government by ruling that the community standards issue alone did not make the law unconstitutional.
The justices then sent the case back for a fuller examination of the other free speech objections raised by the ACLU.
The Philadelphia-based federal appeals court then struck down the law a second time, on much broader grounds.
The law was unconstitutional censorship when it was passed and is both unconstitutional and unnecessary now, the ACLU argued in a court filing. It ignores other, potentially effective tools to protect children, such as filtering software, the ACLU said.
“COPA was passed in 1998, when the Internet was still relatively new and less understood,” ACLU lawyers argued. “COPA’s bludgeon suppresses an enormous amount of speech protected for adults and is unnecessary and ill-tailored to address the government’s interest in protecting children from sexually explicit content.”
The case is Ashcroft v. ACLU, 03-218.
———
On the Net:
Supreme Court: http://www.supremecourtus.gov/
