Skip to content

MEXICAN STANDOFF: Is there enough business to maintain three Mexican restaurants in McMinnville?

MEXICAN STANDOFF: Is there enough business to maintain three Mexican restaurants in McMinnville?

Bartender Amy Foutch mixes a drink at La Cazona. The new Mexican restaurant, which opened Tuesday, features a full bar and plans weekend entertainment such as a mariachi band. (James Clark photo)
The new Mexican restaurant in Northgate Shopping Center named La Cazona officially opened yesterday.

Fiesta Ranchero expanded to open its second restaurant in town about a month ago.

That makes McMinnville home to three Mexican restaurants – four if you count La Mexicano on New Smithville Highway which largely caters to Hispanics.

So the big question is: Can a town the size of McMinnville support so many Mexican restaurants? Will they all be able to stay in business?

What makes the competition even stiffer is all the Mexican restaurants are located within a one-mile radius of one another.

“We’re not scared. We’re not going to let it bother us,” said Fiesta Ranchero owner Erasmo Onate when asked about the arrival of La Cazona. Onate opened Fiesta Ranchero in Plaza Shopping Center 11 years ago. He also has restaurants in Smithville and Shelbyville in addition to his two in McMinnville.

Onate has been living in Shelbyville but says he’s moving back to McMinnville in the next few weeks to help operate the two restaurants here. Oscar Marquez has been managing both Fiesta Rancheros here and he admits business has been a bit slow since Christmas, but says that’s normal for January. He is confident in the quality food and service his restaurant provides.

“We have the best waiters and the best cooks and people really like our food,” said Marquez, who has 18 years of restaurant experience. “I think people will try the other restaurant, but our good customers will come back to us.”

La Cazona is a different type of Mexican restaurant with a heavy emphasis on atmosphere and originality. Even with a more upscale dining room, most items on La Cazona’s menu don’t cost more than $7.99.

“We’re going to be different,” said owner Manuel Ochoa. “We’re going to have brunch on Sundays and a mariachi band on the weekends. In the summer we’re going to open up the patio for outside dining.”

Ochoa is no stranger to the restaurant business either. He owns two restaurants similar to La Cazona in California and has plans to open another restaurant in Cookeville next year. Ochoa is also proud of his chef, Javier Zambrano, who comes from California and has worked hard training kitchen workers here in McMinnville.

“Our purpose is to be consistent with our flavor,” said Zambrano. “We have standard items you can get almost anywhere, but our specialty items are much different.”

Those specialty items include steak, pork and seafood dishes. There is a T-bone steak and red snapper dish.

Restaurants – and most retail stores in general – experience slow sales during the chill of January and February, so the next two months might not be an accurate indication of what’s in store for McMinnville’s sudden abundance of Mexican restaurants. Business traditionally picks up in the middle of March when spring begins to show its face.

Is a town the size of McMinnville too small to support the two new Mexican restaurants which opened in the last month? Maybe. Or maybe Warren County residents have such a love for Mexican food, they can all happily co-exist.

Leave a Comment