Skip to content

Myers says victim ‘like a daughter’: Jury deliberates but can’t reach a verdict

Myers says victim 'like a daughter': Jury deliberates but can't reach a verdict

CLEMINTINE MYERS
Jurors slept on the fate of Clementine Myers last night and returned this morning to enter their second day of deliberations in the murder-for-hire case against the 67-year-old grandmother.

“I thought a lot of Dianne. She was like a sister or daughter,” said Myers, who took the stand in her own behalf Wednesday as testimony concluded in the case. “Jessica used to call me granny.”

Myers faces charges of murder conspiracy and criminal responsibility for murder for her alleged role in the July 30, 1999 deaths of Dianne Watts, 42, Jessica Watts, 10, and Chelsie Smith, 13. The victims were beaten to death inside the Watts’ Myers Lane home by Clementine Myers’ son and Dianne Watts’ longtime boyfriend, Doug Myers, 44. He is serving a life sentence following his conviction for the murders last year.

His partner in crime, Johnny Lewis, 42, is serving 65 years in prison following his conviction on charges of facilitation of murder and aggravated arson, for setting a fire at the residence to cover the crime.

It is her alleged involvement in making payments to Lewis for his role in the crime that has Ms. Myers looking at the possibility of life in prison. Prosecutors say Ms. Myers made payments to Lewis following the murders, apparently for his help and continued silence. Witnesses, including Myers’ own son, Gary Myers, testified they saw the defendant counting out large sums of money shortly after the crime, presumably to pay Lewis.

However, during her testimony, Ms. Myers said she had nothing to do with the murders or the cover up, denying she ever paid Lewis any money.

Myers scoffed at her son’s testimony that he saw her counting out $100 bills in her kitchen to give to Lewis, saying she is raising a handicapped child and is on a fixed income.

“I wish I had a Prince Albert can full of $100 bills,” Myers said.

Her attorney, Bob Peters, suggested Gary Myers made up the story because he is also charged with murder conspiracy and may get a good deal when his case comes up.

Myers admitted she talked to Dianne Watts hours before she was murdered, saying she warned her to “be careful” because she thought there could be payback for a burglary at Gary Myers’ home weeks before. Myers testified she did not specifically know Watts was a target, but instead was concerned for her safety.

“I thought something might happen out at Blues Hill and I told her not to be going up there,” Myers testified, noting she did mention “some people from Grundy County” could be paid $5,000 to take care of problems. She denied the statement was meant as a threat.

As for the alleged payoff to Lewis, Myers brought her neighbor and McMinnville city alderman Jimmy Bonner to the stand. Bonner testified he did not see Lewis nor his vehicle at Myers’ residence the morning of the murders as Gary Myers had testified.

On cross-examination, District Attorney General Dale Potter pointed to Clementine Myers’ alleged threats to “take care of the problem” when it came to Watts’ reported plans to tell authorities of illegal activities by Doug Myers and his associates.

Myers, who responded she did not know Watts was going to turn anyone in to lawmen, was met with a loud retort by Potter.

“She never got a chance to turn anyone in, did she,” Potter said, ending his cross-examination.

Deliberations resume today at the White County Courthouse where the trial was held due to a change of venue. Jurors deliberated around six hours Thursday.

Leave a Comment