Skip to content

Top 10 Warren County court stories of 2003

A record number of cases was heard during 2003, some settled by plea prior to trial and others decided by a jury of 12.

With the exception of two juvenile court cases, the consensus top 10 court cases of 2003 were all heard in circuit court. The cases ranged from child molestation and child abuse to robbery and murder.

The following is a synopsis of the top 10 local cases which appeared in the Southern Standard during 2003:

Eric Sullivan, Margie Farley convicted
Both Eric Sullivan and Margie Farley were convicted for their various roles in the beating death and robbery of Louis Johnson, 63, in May 2000. They were both arrested shortly after the crime and remained in jail through their trials.

Prosecutors proved it was Sullivan who fatally attacked Johnson with a tire tool outside the victim’s trailer, finding him guilty of murder and robbery. A separate jury then found Farley guilty of facilitation of murder and robbery for taking Sullivan to the residence and then luring the victim, who was a friend, outside to be attacked. Sullivan was sentenced to 45 years and Farley 37 years.

Wiley teens avoid adult prosecution
A juvenile court judge released two teen-age defendants following a hearing of their case in juvenile court.

The boys, Brandon Wiley, 15, and G.W. Wiley, 17, were charged with attempted murder for allegedly attacking their father, Dr. Gregory Wiley, with a hammer. Dr. Wiley suffered serious head injuries but recovered. The incident occurred just before Christmas 2002 inside the family’s home.

During juvenile hearings, Brandon Wiley, who used the hammer on his father, maintained he was defending his brother, whom his father had pushed down the steps. Dr. Wiley denied pushing his oldest son but backed off of an earlier theory that the boys had conspired to murder him.

The juvenile judge found G.W. Wiley not guilty in the crime and then released Brandon Wiley on probation for his part in the incident. The victim, Dr. Wiley, was ordered to pay child support for his two children who were placed in the custody of their mother.

Jones starves Anderson to death
A caregiver was sentenced to 21 years in prison after she was found guilty of starving mentally challenged Fletcher Anderson, 68, to death.

Prosecutors told jurors Anderson weighed only 81 pounds at the time of his death, maintaining Jones took Anderson into her care when his nursing home closed so she could collect his government check. Prosecutors told jurors Jones denied the victim food and kept him locked in a room.

Ginn convicted of killing friend
Jeremiah Ginn, 27, was sentenced to serve 24 years in prison after he was convicted for second-degree murder for the stabbing death of his long-time friend, Robert Webb Jr. 26.

The defense maintained Ginn acted in self-defense, fatally stabbing Webb outside his (Ginn’s) home when Webb came to confront him. However, prosecutors countered that Ginn continued to stab his friend after the victim was already subdued, lying on the ground bleeding from the initial knife attack. Lawmen also pointed to evidence Ginn staged the crime scene by firing Webb’s gun into his house, making it appear as if Webb had shot at him.

Lance acquitted in friend’s death
Thomas Lance walked from the courtroom a free man this February when jurors found he did not kill his long-time friend Lee Neal.

Lance had served two years in jail since his arrest for the crime in July 2000. Lance had been accused of setting fire to his friend’s trailer, killing Neal. Prosecutors maintained the two had fought and Lance doused the trailer in kerosene and set it afire. The defense maintained the fire was accidental and Lance had no reason to kill his friend. Jurors did not find evidence to bring a conviction, resulting in the acquittal.

Teens sentenced for teacher threats
Two 16-year-old Warren Academy students were committed to the Department of Youth Development for threatening to shoot teachers at the alternative school this Fall.

Joshua Polson Rigsby was committed until his 19th birthday while Joshua Lee was committed for an indefinite period. Rigsby entered a plea to filing a false report while Lee was later convicted of filing a false report. They were originally charged with attempted murder.

The teens were charged after they reportedly warned a teacher not to be at school the following day, saying they were going to bring a gun to school shoot teachers. When caught by lawmen later, the teens had a rifle in the trunk of the car in which they were riding. The teens claimed it was a misunderstanding; however, the court believed the teachers’ version.

Serial robber acquitted
A man with 11 prior armed robbery convictions was acquitted by a Warren County jury following a trial which saw two eye-witnesses identify him as the man who robbed two local stores in 2002.

Daniel Whited, 46, was acquitted for robbing Pump n Pay and Pit Stop North in May 2002. The acquittal came after two witnesses, one from each heist, testified they saw Whited actually commit the crimes. However, the defense countered by offering testimony from alibi witnesses who said they saw Whited elsewhere at the time one of the robberies were committed. Jurors apparently believed the alibi and discounted the eye-witness testimony. Jurors were not told of his prior convictions in the state of Florida.

Whited was later arrested by federal authorities and is serving time for possessing a firearm while being a convicted felon.

Teen sentenced for baby abuse
A 17-year-old was sentenced to three years in prison for critically injuring her 5-week-old son.

Anias Ramirez, 17 when the incident occurred, stood trial as an adult and was convicted on the charge of reckless aggravated assault for shaking and throwing her baby. Prosecutors maintained Ramirez became irritated when the child kept crying, prompting her to abuse the baby. The child suffered permanent brain injuries due to the abuse.

Her mother, Ivallessee Rodriguez, 35, was placed on probation for three years for failing to report the baby’s injuries.

Minister jailed for child molestation
Gath Baptist youth minister Jeffery Simmons was given the maximum 48-year sentence after he was convicted of molesting an 8-year-old girl in his home.

Simmons was arrested in 2000 after allegations were made. In the case of the 8-year-old, the girl testified Simmons touched her in her private areas while she was spending the night on several occasions with Simmons’ daughter. Simmons still faces allegations for four more children.

McCormick pleas to Tanner murder
Jody Lee McCormick was sentenced to life in prison after he entered a plea this November to the 2002 strangulation death of Viola Highway car lot owner Junior Tanner.

McCormick, 29, admitted he strangled Tanner to death after Tanner cut him outside the car lot. McCormick went to the lot to rob the establishment and was confronted by the owner. McCormick claimed he did not intend to kill him.

After killing the victim, McCormick pulled Tanner into a trailer and set the trailer afire to destroy the evidence. McCormick’s blood was found at the scene of the crime and several of Tanner’s possessions were found on the defendant when he was arrested.

Leave a Comment