Skip to content

School board favors fairer insurance for employees

Believing that all public school employees in the state ought to have access to equal insurance benefits, the Warren County School Board is urging the General Assembly to rectify what the board sees as an unfair practice.

As it now stands, the state funds 45 percent of the health insurance costs of certified personnel, that is teachers and most administrators, while it pays nothing toward the costs of non-certified personnel like custodians, cafeteria workers, secretaries and bookkeepers.

“This would make things a lot fairer,” board member Mike Holland said of the board’s proposed resolution. “All of our employees work for the same school system, yet the non-certified folks don’t get anything in the way of insurance.”

With 315 employees, the number of local non-certified personnel make up nearly half the school system’s workforce. Of these, a majority are full-time and thus eligible to participate in the state’s health insurance plan. However, these individuals must pay substantially more than the system’s teachers for the same coverage.

For example, the state’s PPO plan costs county teachers $196.38 per month for single coverage and $490.12 per month for family coverage. For the same plan, non-certified personnel must pay $357.05 per month for single coverage and $891.13 per month for family coverage.

“A lot of our non-certified employees just can’t afford that,” said Holland. “And some of them who do take the insurance are working just for that purpose. They are not bringing home any money at all. At most, they’re subsisting.

“If the state could fund 45 percent of their insurance too it would be a lot more affordable for them. Maybe then they could go from just surviving to being able to afford a few luxuries.”

The board’s proposed resolution, drafted by board attorney Michael Galligan, will first be submitted to the Tennessee School Boards Association. Should it meet with the approval of that organization, it will then be submitted to the General Assembly for consideration.

After reviewing a copy of the resolution state Rep. Judd Matheny said he was in total agreement.

“I support the concept completely. Non-certified personnel should be able to get the same rates and benefits as certified personnel,” Matheny said. “Health insurance is a fundamental need. It’s not something that’s experience-dependent like a pay scale.”

While many of Matheny’s colleagues in Nashville may also agree with the resolution in theory, both Holland and the representative noted action may not be taken immediately due its funding requirements and the current cash-strapped nature of the state.

According to the state Department of Education’s Web site, there were over 44,000 non-certified public school employees in the state during the 2001-2002 school year, the most recent year for which statistics are available. If the state were to pay 45 percent of just the single coverage option of the PPO plan mentioned above for each of these 44,000, the cost to the state would be over $84 million a year using this year’s insurance costs.

“We’ll have to wait and see what kind of fiscal note would be attached to a bill like this before we could make any final decisions,” said Matheny. “Timing may not allow it to happen this year, but something is going to have to happen. This is something we have to fix.”

Leave a Comment