Upon Further Review: Title IX hurts more sports than it helps
|
In 1972 congress enacted the Title IX of the Education Amendments to prohibit gender discrimination in the nation’s education programs.It states: “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.”
Now with that said, Title IX was originally put into place for education purposes and not meant to become a battle over men and women’s athletic programs. It was meant to correct problems in areas like admissions and appointments in higher education, problems we had back in the ’70s.
Over the past several years’ organizations for the equal rights of women have taken this ruling and ran with it, creating many problems for universities and high schools.
First, let me say as a father of two girls who play ball: One at the high school level. Programs should be given equal opportunities. But the question is how do you give them equal billing when one sport generates income and the others don’t break even? Some will say this is where the booster clubs should help out the funding, and they do. But what about big ticket items like bleachers or lights? Should parents be responsible for securing those types of items?
With funding becoming more and more difficult for athletic departments every year, the answer is yes, if you want to see programs grow at the high school level.
But what about the college programs? Over the past year several universities have chosen to shut down some of their men’s athletic programs in order to meet the Title IX requirements.
Since 1992 over 350 men’s athletic teams have been eliminated across the country. Since Title IX has been in effect the number of girls participating in high school sports have grown substantially. In 2002 over 2.8 million girls played high school sports compared to 4 million boys.
But the problem is when these athletes reach the college level. Gender equality is being achieved not by increasing female opportunities, but by reducing male opportunities. Let’s cut the male athletic departments in order to make the numbers match. I believe Title IX is being used as a scapegoat and the real culprit is spending cuts and the lack of funding by the government.
Yes, Title IX is to provide girls and boys the same amount of money to be used for equipment, uniforms, coaches and facilities, but if the state or federal government doesn’t provide the funding all this is a moot point.
With the number of universities cutting back on athletic programs, only a relatively small number of high school athletes will be able to participate in varsity sports at the college level.
We have reduced male programs without achieving a surge in women’s athletics. The numbers look good on paper. But the only thing that has changed is the number of male programs that have been cut. It’s like everything else, it’s all about money!
