Skip to content

Bonnaroo controversy still raging: Smartt wants to see proof of statements made in court

Bonnaroo controversy still raging: Smartt wants to see proof of statements made in court

ROWLAND
Saying the sheriff’s department should be ready to back up sworn statements made in court, County Commissioner George Smartt says he hopes next year’s handling of Bonneroo will be different.

Meanwhile, Sheriff Jackie Matheny defends his department’s handling of the heavy Bonneroo traffic and the stops that were made, noting there will continue to be stepped-up enforcement during special events. He denies there was any intentional profiling, saying instead most cars on the road were heading to Bonneroo, thereby giving out-of-towners a higher ticket rate.

“If they are going to make a statement in open court, then they better be ready to back it up,” Smartt said, referring to statements reportedly made in court by Chief Investigator Herb Rowland that local cars were also ticketed during stepped-up enforcement the weekend of Bonneroo last month.

General Sessions Judge Larry Ross, who threw out citations against 24 out-of-town Bonneroo patrons due to concerns about profiling, indicated a search of court records found no local citations filed during the same time period, aside from one ticket given to a Tracy City man on Highway 108. Ross said he could not publicly comment on the situation since he was the presiding judge in the cases.

“I just think it looks bad on us, to be singling out people because they are not from around here,” Smartt said. “I hope things will be done differently next time.”

In response, Matheny said lawmen were only doing their job by stopping speeders and issuing citations when drugs were found. Matheny noted there were literally thousands of cars carrying Bonneroo-goers passing through the county and at one point, only about 1 in 20 cars were from Warren County. Matheny further said lawmen were giving speeders a grace period of 10 miles over the speed limit before they made stops.

“If you stick your head in a window and get knocked over by the smell of drugs, do you just let them go along their way?” Matheny asked. “There were several cars we stopped, and I was personally there, where we let them go with a warning. I’m sworn to uphold the law here, and if there’s drugs in a car, it would be wrong for us to just let them go.”

As for Rowland’s testimony that other citations were given, Matheny said there were other arrests that came in the same time period, including the arrest of a meth suspect made while lawmen were moving from one position to another at the time of the stepped-up enforcement.

“Any statement he (Rowland) made on the stand was something he believed to be true,” Matheny said.

Along with statements made after the fact, Smartt is also concerned with statements reportedly made before the Bonneroo incident. Specifically, Smartt said Sheriff’s Chief Deputy Danice Taylor and County Commissioner Gary Prater had a heated argument in a commission meeting just before Bonneroo.

“I thought it might come to blows,” Smartt said of the disagreement between Taylor, who is also a commissioner, and Prater.

Smartt said the unrest came after Taylor claimed the county was “going to get its share” of revenue by catching Bonneroo-goers with drugs while noting Prater was already getting his share by selling barbecue from his business at the event.

In response, Matheny said those words were likely spoken in the heat of debate by his chief deputy, noting Taylor did not participate in the stepped-up enforcement.

“If you’re going to blame anybody, blame me,” Matheny said. “I announced there would be stepped-up enforcement because of the increased traffic and my men, and they are good officers, were only doing what they thought was right. We weren’t out there to single out anyone and I’m sorry it appeared that way. They didn’t expect they would be on trial when they went to court. But I think what has brought a lot of this debate is some folks who are worried about losing business.”

Matheny said the Bonneroo incident will not deter his department from conducting stepped-up enforcement activities around special events.

“The judge (Larry Ross) did what he thought was right,” Matheny said. “While we might not agree with it, that’s his job. By the same token, we’re going to continue doing our jobs.”

Leave a Comment