Skip to content

Media Musings: The role of journalism in war

More than 500 journalists have been trained by the Pentagon for war coverage and now they are moving, along with troops, into position. Theirs is one of the most glamorous and dangerous of all assignments, and they deserve our respect for asking to be aboard as the war begins.

It’s obvious to me that nothing now will stop President Bush from his desire to reshape the entire Middle East forever and that Iraq is his starting place. There are so many dangers there in terms of foreign policy formation and unforeseen debacles that no prophet will really be able to prepare us for what may be a protracted military and financial burden that literally destroys our ability to pay for it.

Even so, these men and women will do their best to tell us of the many stories of average men and women who bear the burdens of combat. The most surprising story of all, however, is the Pentagon is shifting its coverage policy for the first time since Vietnam.

Desert Storm was a video game to the American people, where good old Gen. Swartzkopf and his information staff gave us graphs and lectures and only what they wanted us to know. It was better than the 5 o’clock follies in Vietnam, which reporters went to for amusement because it was only the latest spin on a war the nation never supported. The body bags and never-ending statements that victory was at hand, which were false, destroyed press briefings.

After the war, for a while, the Pentagon argued the press crippled its ability to prosecute the war. But military historians now believe it was a huge credibility gap between the American people and the executive branch that sealed our fate in Vietnam. The greatest lesson from Vietnam is that no war effort can be prosecuted for long without the support of the American people.

It’s an obvious truth that the terrorist attacks changed American feelings about war because it’s not the Hollywood war movies that run endlessly on cable channels, but terrorism using commercial airplanes and box cutters.

While the Pentagon has not dwelled on its change in coverage policy, it is going public with statements that say, in sum, even granting the terrorist attacks and a change in public opinion, we know that openness about the invasions will grant us credibility.

However, there are serious news organizations that know all too well the hi-jinks of Vietnam and do not want their reporters compromised by military information officers spinning away the truth. Cynics have every right to hold such views given Desert Storm and Vietnam, but the proof will be in the quality and diversity of the coverage.

Here’s a story to look for: Beyond patriotism and jingoism, what is the fate of the thousands, perhaps hundreds of thousands, of women, children, and families? Forget that collateral damage language from the Pentagon. They are the innocents living under the heel of a dictator. Their story must be told. And, if you want to be crass about it, when the president announces a $100 billion relief plan for Iraq, that coverage might help the nation be more willing to place such a massive financial burden on its children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren.

What impresses the most about the change of policy is that the Pentagon has granted press credentials to Al Jazeera, the Arab television news network. That’s a masterstroke, because the Arab world has the potential to become a permanent enemy of this nation. The power of Islam is real and it is now a religious war to many of its most powerful intellectuals and leaders. The network has credibility and the Pentagon’s decision is wise policy.

(Ed Kimbrell is a professor in MTSU’s School of Journalism.)

Leave a Comment