Skip to content

Hillis says work was set up to fail by road superintendent: Local road paver says his work meets state specifications

Hillis says work was set up to fail by road superintendent: Local road paver says his work meets state specifications

HILLIS
The continuing controversy over the operation of the Warren County Highway Department and comments current Road Superintendent Harold Glenn made in an article in the Southern Standard concerning the quality of work from the Hillis Group, has led owner and operator Stan Hillis to address Glenn’s charges directly.

“In response to Harold and Levie Glenn’s accusations about unsatisfactory work and materials, we spend thousands of dollars each year on mix designs according to TDOT specifications,” Hillis said. “All we can do is bid and do mix according to TDOT mix designs. Our mix was within specifications.”

Hillis also addressed a photo of his work on Dark Hollow Road that was used to illustrate accusations of poor workmanship.

“As far as satisfactory work on Dark Hollow Road, anyone can clearly see the shoulders are breaking because they were not prepared to be paved, which was the responsibility of the county,” Hillis pointed out.

Hillis also says Glenn went to the job site and directed his foreman to widen the road two feet, requiring him to do some grading on the shoulders, which workers did at no charge to the county, according to Hillis foreman Don Brigham. Hillis said they realized paving over dirt would result in possible problems, but they did as they were directed by Glenn.

“You can’t pave on dirt and soft spots without the paving coming up,” he said. “It needs to be dug out and rocked in with shoulder stone and then paved.”

Hillis and Brigham further stipulated that Glenn made other changes to normal paving procedures on Dark Hollow Road.

“He told us to use between an inch and a half to two inches of asphalt average over the whole job” Brigham said. “We averaged an inch and three quarters.”

Normally for a project of this sort, the pavers would have done two layers where one layer of pavement would have been laid down, and then another over that one to strengthen the pavement. In addition to the widening on the unprepared shoulders, Hillis says Glenn told his pavers to put down only one layer on Dark Hollow Road.

Thinking little of it at the time, Hillis now feels these were calculated moves to limit the durability of the road. This gave Glenn a chance to use the condition of the road to indicate poor workmanship as wear on the unprepared shoulders began to show up in a relatively short period.

“We were set up to fail on this one,” Hillis said.

He also feels the bid process is being abused to limit the number of bidders for the county’s yearly paving contract.

Hillis said at one point a paving company had 10 days to begin a paving job when informed by the highway department. He says that Glenn has now reduced this time constraint to three days, after which, if the company with the bid hasn’t started the project, Glenn can then use the next highest bidder, which in this case would be APAC. Hillis maintains if a company was caught in the middle of a job it would be difficult to meet the three-day limit.

There is also the issue of fair competition and the effect having more than one bidder can have on the prices the county is charged for paving. Last year, there were only two bidders, APAC and the Hillis Group. APAC’s bid for “C” mix, which the county uses almost exclusively, was $26.75 per ton. The Hillis Group bid was $25.49 – or $1.26 less.

If Hillis doesn’t bid on road work, then APAC could conceivably bid and charge an even higher amount, particularly with oil prices going up, and with no competition, would automatically be awarded the bid.

Hillis isn’t the only local paving company that has had issues dealing with Harold Glenn. Hillis’ former partner, Jimmy Yates, says he sold out his paving company, Custom, to APAC because of those problems.

“I just got tired of the struggle and hassle with it,” Yates said. “It’s just hard to work for somebody who doesn’t want you out there.”

Much like Stanley Hillis, Yates said he never got any state-aid work from the county either.

“And that’s where you make your money,” he said.

Yates says much of Glenn’s popularity stems from the amount of work his substantial budget allows him to do. Yates pointed out the highway department budget for 2002-03 was over $3 million.

“Anybody could be road commissioner with the money they’re getting these days,” Yates said.

Glenn has also come under scrutiny lately due to the four-day work week implemented for the highway department. Highway and Bridge Committee Chairman Gary Prater says he received several calls during the recent snows and bad weather inquiring why the department was closed on Fridays. Apparently many people were unaware the highway department works four 10-hour days and is off on Fridays. According to Hillis, this is something he requires his contractors to do as well in most cases since no county inspectors or highway employees are available on Fridays.

Hillis summed up his problems with Glenn in this statement.

“It is hard to please someone when he wants someone else to do his work. We will continue to bid and try harder to please the Glenns, as we have been doing satisfactorily for Van Buren and DeKalb counties and the state of Tennessee for years. It is good enough for them, it should be satisfactory to Warren County also,” he said.

As to rumors he is considering legal action, Hillis only had this comment.

“We will do whatever we have to,” he said.

Leave a Comment