Skip to content

Judge expected to rule on Wiley case Thursday:If found guilty, teens may face confinement till 19th birthdays

Judge expected to rule on Wiley case Thursday:If found guilty, teens may face confinement till 19th birthdays

G.W. Wiley, facing camera, gives a tearful good-bye hug to, from left, his brother Brandon, mother Bernita and sister Brittany Wiley following a hearing Tuesday. (Duane Sherrill photo)
The fate of two brothers accused of attacking their father with a hammer last December rests in the hands of the juvenile court with a decision expected Thursday.

Gregory (G.W.) Wiley Jr., 18, and Brandon Wiley, 15, are both charged in juvenile petitions with attempted first-degree murder for the Dec. 13 hammer beating of their father, Dr. Gregory Wiley. They were tried as juveniles Tuesday after Juvenile Court Judge Larry Ross denied a state attempt to try the boys as adults.

“I need to take some time with this because I have two young lives in my hands,” said special Juvenile Court Judge Donna Scott of Murfreesboro following a four-hour hearing Tuesday. Scott replaced Ross because he had earlier heard evidence in a detention hearing, thereby removing him from further juvenile hearings on the case.

Scott said she will render her decision Thursday, either in person or by writing to the attorneys. Should she find guilt on either or both teens, a hearing would be held to decide what fate the boys will face.

“Our purpose here is to treat and rehabilitate, not to punish,” Scott said. The maximum either teen could face is confinement until their 19th birthdays with the department of youth development.

Had they been tried and convicted as adults, they could have faced 15 to 25 years in prison.

Scott took the case under advisement after hearing prosecutors say Brandon Wiley confessed to hitting his father in the head with a hammer twice. However, in his confession, the younger Wiley said he struck his father because the doctor had pushed his brother down the steps of their Francis Ferry Road home on the evening of Dec. 13. Dr. Wiley denies pushing his son down the stairs.

The confrontation which led up to the hammer attack allegedly began when Dr. Wiley and his eldest son were discussing $700 the teen had removed from his father’s checking account without permission. The teen told his father he took the money to buy Christmas presents.

During testimony Tuesday, Dr. Wiley said he told G.W. to go to his room, but instead the normally mindful youth moved slowly toward his room, prompting his father to follow him. Prosecutors maintain the older brother was luring his father into a preconceived trap.

“He was just standing atop the steps and he had a weird look on his face,” Dr. Wiley testified, noting he does not know if G.W. saw his younger brother coming up behind him with the hammer. Wiley said he did not realize he had been hit with a hammer until much later. The doctor suffered a skull fracture which required four plates to be put in his head.

In the face of the proof, Public Defender Dan Bryant, who represents the younger brother, said the court should consider the lesser charge of aggravated assault in his client’s case since the youth was allegedly coming to the defense of his older brother.

In opposition, District Attorney General Dale Potter pointed to the testimony of Brandon’s twin sister, Brittany Wiley, who told lawmen Brandon had come to her room with a hammer earlier in the day before the assault, and said he would like to hit their father with the hammer for the way he was treating his older brother.

“He (Brandon) was very protective of G.W.,” Brittany Wiley testified.

At the close of evidence, G.W. Wiley’s attorney, Billy Tollison, said prosecutors had no direct evidence his client was involved in any assault conspiracy. Potter disagreed, maintaining Brandon was being controlled by his older brother who was mad because their father had taken his car and revoked his privileges due to the check stealing incident.

G.W. Wiley, flanked by his natural mother Bernita Wiley, spoke briefly while leaving the courtroom following Tuesday’s hearing. He turned 18 while in juvenile custody and is now free on bond awaiting the outcome of his case.

“I love him,” a tearful and soft spoken Wiley said of his father. “I still want to have a relationship with my dad.”

His statement came after he gave a long, tearful good-bye hug to his younger brother who was taken back to juvenile detention in Cookeville following the hearing.

Leave a Comment