Skip to content

Taste of freedom: Lance served over two years in jail before jury found him not guilty

Taste of freedom: Lance served over two years in jail before jury found him not guilty

Thomas Lance talked to the Standard on Monday about the emotional turmoil he endured over the last two years. Lance was jailed for allegedly murdering his best friend. (Duane Sherrill photo)
For two and a half years, an eight-by-eight cell was home for Thomas Lance, a man accused of murdering his best friend. It was an allegation jurors also found false Saturday.

“It’s hard to put how this feels into words,” said Lance Monday during an interview with the Southern Standard on just his second day of freedom. “It feels great to be out because for a while I was thinking I might never get out. There were times I just felt helpless, like no one believed me.”

Lance’s 30-month ordeal began in August 2000 when he was arrested for the death of his friend, Lee Neal, 21, who died in a trailer fire. Lawmen believed it was Lance who started the fire, pointing to kerosene found at the scene and kerosene on Lance’s clothes. They also thought his alibi, that he had left the trailer an hour before and passed out in a nearby car, did not add up. However, jurors believed the defense’s scenario that the fire was an accident and that kerosene traces found on Lance’s shirt were from carrying a kerosene heater for storage earlier the day of the fire.

“When I saw the fire, I was in a state of shock,” Lance said, recalling when the flicking of the flames awoke him. “Him dying like that just wasn’t right. It was almost like I was having a bad dream.

“He was my best friend. Where you saw one of us, you saw the other. We always got along. And his parents, Don and Kathy, they were like my mother and father and now they think I did it and I hate they feel that way.”

Lance said it only poured salt in his wound from losing his friend when officers arrested him for murder.

“It’s terrible the way they treat people and get away with it,” Lance said of some of the officers who charged him. “There are some honest officers, like Jackie (Matheny) Jr., and then there are others who aren’t honest at all. They made me feel like trash.”

What followed was 30 months in Warren County Jail, much of which was spent in the maximum security area where he existed in an eight-by-eight cell — with cellmates.

“It’s terrible out there,” Lance said of the jail, noting his bond was set at $300,000, meaning he could not possibly get out while awaiting trial. “They should have at least given me a chance to make bond, but $300,000, only a rich man could make that.”

After turning down an offer to plea to a reduced charge of 20 years in jail, Lance said he waited anxiously for his trial.

“I prayed every day and knew the Lord would provide for me,” Lance said.

When his trial began, Lance said he was surprisingly calm until it was time for him to take the stand.

“I tried to look all of them jurors in the eye,” Lance said. “I wanted to take the stand to tell them the truth. While I was on the stand I was nervous but I felt good because I could see they were listening to me and some of them were taking notes.”

Lance said the scariest time was when the jury came back after an hour of deliberation. The announcement of the verdict really did not sink in for a while.

Within hours, Lance was released from jail on bond. He faces aggravated assault charges for an alleged incident while he was in jail, a crime he says he did not commit.

“The first thing I did when I got out was have a cigarette,” Lance said. “I didn’t have an appetite the first night, but had my first home-cooked meal in nearly three years the next day.”

Lance said he plans to make the best of his freedom and become a productive member of the community, perhaps starting his own business.

“I learned not to take life for granted,” Lance said. “The two years I was in jail, that wasn’t right.”

Lance said he knows many in the community still think he was guilty of murder, but hopes with time they will understand he had nothing to do with it.

“I want people to know I’m not a bad person and I always try to be honest,” Lance said. “It may take a while but I hope in time people realize this.”

Even with his freedom, Lance said he will continue missing his friend. As far as what caused the tragic death of Neal, Lance said all he can assume is the fire was an accident since he can think of no one who would want to kill his friend.

Leave a Comment