Media Musings: Ups and downs of Nashville media
This time of the year the media look back at 2002 to list the biggest news stories of the year, the deaths of famous people, and the promise and perils facing the world as 2003 dawns.
I will join in that review briefly to focus on a few local media hoping that they will, collectively, continue to strive for excellence or get their groove back.
First up is the confusing story of the decline of the Nashville Scene, once so important a voice of alternative journalism in the area it was called, by some, Nashville’s only newspaper. Today, it lives in the shadow of its glory days.
Gone are some great writers such as Henry Walker, who, when on his game, was the best media critic in the area and there are so few of them now they are on an endangered species list. Walker made mistakes. Walker sometimes over-reached his facts. But he should have worn the hatred of him by the corporate Tennessean as a bragging right. Then there is the absence of investigative reporter Willy Stern, who is gifted at wheedling a story out of a source. Seldom does his byline appear.
Under the leadership of Bruce Dobie – in my book the best editor in Nashville – the paper covered civil rights, police brutality, architecture and city planning with articles laced with fact and opinion. The Scene, as the old statement went, was a must-read. It is no longer. Yet, Dobie is still at his desk.
The answer appears to be corporate ownership. Bought by The Village Voice of New York, which itself is no longer the passionate voice of Norman Mailer, The Scene became a holding, rather than a deeply concerned media citizen. Dobie and Del Favero got rich when the paper sold-perhaps a just reward for building such an interesting alternative paper-but it seems like the very soul of the paper went out the door when the ink on the deal dried. The paper no longer raises hell and we’re the poorer for it.
Second up, the rise of Channel 5 in the areas of sports and investigative reporting. Give it to MTSU alum Phil Williams. Any reporter who can get the Governor willing to swear on a Bible that he’s a truthful man as the FBI is seizing the files of apparently a sweetheart deal between the governor and an old pal, is doing fine work.
There’s no match in Nashville TV for its sports department and with veteran Hope Hines, an Emmy winner, at its helm it offers a consistent in-depth (well, for TV that is) sports report that is entertaining, fair and informative.
Third up, the rise of WWTN, a talk station No. 1 in Nashville radio. It rose as it became a relentless one-story station, pounding the proposed state income tax with bad information, twisted information, and lots of venting listeners. It has worked for Rush Limbaugh for many, many years on the national scene.
Fourth up, the boring Tennessean. Big, wealthy, burdened by a heavy bureaucracy as part of the Gannett powerhouse, the paper, to many members of the power-elite, no longer sets any agenda. The Tennessean has tried to hammer Murfreesboro’s Daily News Journal and Franklin’s Review Appeal with AMs but both have not given any ground.
However, some focus groups or just a good decision somewhere revived the paper’s interest in books and it should be applauded for linking with the city’s libraries to promote books in the best section in the Sunday paper, the magazine. If the trend on the magazine continues upward, it might be the THE reason to buy the Sunday product.
(Ed Kimbrell is a professor in MTSU’s School of Journalism.)
