Upon Further Review: All-stars a matter of popularity
|
There was a time when the All-star game meant something. It rewarded the best players in the league for their hard work and effort.
But now it seems it is more of a popularity contest — it doesn’t matter if you’re leading the league with the best batting average or you have committed the fewest errors. So, let’s not call it the All-star game.
Instead, let’s call it the Mr. Congeniality contest.
It’s not about who’s the best player anymore. If you want to make the All-star team all you have to do is socialize with the fans. Sign a few autographs or do a few commercials and the fans are sure to vote you in regardless of how bad a season you’re having.
OK, the fans have that right. They are the ones who pay all that money to watch a baseball game, and if they want to see their favorite player out there in the All-star contest, then so be it. But if that’s the case, then it’s not an All-star game anymore.
The All-star game is supposed to reward those players who are having a good season and are at the top of their game. At least that’s the way it used to be.
As a manager, is it right to pick six or seven of your own players? Last year Yankees manager Joe Torre picked seven of his own players. This year Jason Giambi, Jorge Posada and Alfonso Soriano were voted on by the fans, then Torre picked closer Mariano Rivera, shortstop Derek Jeter and third baseman Robin Ventura. Jeter and Ventura are not having All-star years, but they’re going to be in Milwaukee.
Ichiro was the top vote-getter with 2,516,016 votes. Sammy Sosa led the National League with 2,140,315. There are 25 first-time selections, including four who got voted on by the fans: Boston’s Shea Hillenbrand, Soriano, the Twins’ Torii Hunter and Philadelphia’s Scott Rolen.
The All-star game used to be contested as a matter of pride between the National League and the American League. Now the game is more of an attitude of, “let’s go out there and put our all-star shirts on. If they win, that’s fine, if we win, no big deal.”
The All-star game — like everything else in professional sports — is all about how much money they can make.
As you can tell, I’m not big on the All-star game anymore. It just doesn’t represent the best players in the game anymore. There is always going to be somebody more deserving left off the team.
Maybe they need to pick more players and make it a two-game series. Each team gets 50 of the top players in the league and plays two games. It would make more money and give all the players who deserve to be on the team a chance to shine.
You may think I don’t watch the All-star game. For the most part, you’re right. I’ll watch a few innings then change the channel back and fourth just to keep up with what’s going on in the game.
The one thing I do enjoy, however, is the home run contest. Everybody loves to see the long ball, and to watch some of these guys take cuts that would knock a house down is truly amazing. The year Mark McGwire made the Green Monster at Fenway Park look like a little league field was truly fun to watch.
With that in mind, maybe All-star week isn’t so bad. But it would be more interesting if the best players in baseball were out there and not just the most-liked.
