Skip to content

Saints and Sinners: Questions of the afterlife

A mother whose daughter had died when she was 4 years old wondered whether she will recognize the little girl when they meet again in the resurrection.

“It was 30 years ago when Emily died,” she wrote her minister. “Will she still be a little girl when I see her again or will she be grown up?”

Ralph Sockman, the renowned New York pastor who received the mother’s letter, replied by telling her the story of a lad who had died in his youth. A house was erected by the boy’s father on the Dartmouth College campus in the young man’s memory. In the house was a book containing this touching inscription: “To Edward K. Hall, in recollection of his son and my son who have the privilege by the grace of God to be boys through all eternity.”

It was signed, “Calvin Coolidge.”

Coolidge, who was president of the United States from 1923 to 1929, was a friend of the elder Hall. Coolidge had lost one of his own sons in 1924.

The boy, who was only 16, had been playing tennis on the White House lawn in his sneakers without socks. He developed a blister, which later became infected. Blood poisoning set in and Calvin Jr. died.

It was the deepest tragedy of Coolidge’s life.

On the question of whether the Hall and Coolidge youths would “by the grace of God be boys through all eternity,” Sockman pleaded ignorance as he did to the question of whether Emily would be a little girl forever.

To Emily’ mother, he wrote, “With our finite minds we simply do not know whether growth in the heavenly realm involves those changes which we associate with ‘growing up’ in this world. But, this I firmly believe: family love will find continuance in the hereafter.”

Resurrection — both Jesus’ and our own — has engaged Christians throughout the centuries. We affirm our belief in the hereafter in the creeds: “I believe in the resurrection of the body,” but our belief is based more on faith than evidence.

A recent New York Times story on the resurrection recalled an anecdote about the British philosopher Bertrand Russell who was approached by God after he died and asked why he had failed to believe during his lifetime. Russell replies, “Not enough evidence, God. Not enough evidence.”

Most academic types — particularly scientists — have rejected the resurrection on the same grounds. In the words of the Times article, “Scholars accept the doctrine that a belief is justified only when evidence can be found for it outside the believer’s own mind. It has to be supported by independent proof and, in the opinion of scientific scholars, there simply isn’t any in the case of the resurrection.”

Now, however, some in the academic community are showing renewed interest in the physical resurrection of Jesus. This is said to be a new development in the last 25 years. In April of this year, 100 philosophers who convened at Yale University heard a professor of philosophy from Oxford University, Richard Swinburne, give a reasoned case for Jesus’ resurrection from the dead.

Assigning values to certain probability factors, Swinburne told his rapt audience that he had reached the conclusion that the probability of Jesus’ resurrection comes out to be an astounding 97 percent.

As to how old we will be in heaven, one religious sect puts the figure at 33, which they have established is when we are at our prime.

That leaves open the question, what about those who died before they reached 33, like Emily and the Coolidge and Hall boys? Will they be zapped to 33 upon entering the kingdom? Or will former President Coolidge be right that they will remain boys (and girls) through all eternity? After all, it wouldn’t be heaven without children.

(George Plagenz is a syndicated columnist.)

Leave a Comment