Skip to content

Man, 28, admits murdering Tanner: McCormick says he choked victim to death in scuffle

Man, 28, admits murdering Tanner: McCormick says he choked victim to death in scuffle

MC CORMICK
An acquaintance of murder victim Junior Tanner has confessed to strangling the 57-year-old auto dealer to death at his car lot last month and then burning his body to cover the crime.

The suspect, Jody Lee McCormick, 28, was charged with criminal homicide and aggravated arson following questioning by authorities Monday night, during which the suspect reportedly told lawmen he did not mean to kill Tanner.

“He said he wasn’t a cold-blooded killer and that he’d never done anything like that before and panicked,” said Sheriff Jackie Matheny of McCormick’s confession.

Matheny said McCormick was the prime suspect even before the confession due to information investigators had developed during the two-week probe. Evidence found on McCormick along with his confession just serve to make the case stronger, Matheny noted.

The probe has been ongoing since the morning of May 21 when Tanner was found in the burned remains of the trailer where he lived next to his car lot, J.R. Auto Sales on Highway 108. Investigators soon suspected foul play when a blood trail was found at the crime scene. The scene was investigated for three days by crime labs from the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and Tennessee Fire Marshal’s office.

“We felt strongly that we had a homicide based on what we saw at the scene and the leads we developed,” Matheny said. “We eliminated all suspects except for Mr. McCormick and we would have likely charged him even without his statement. He kind of slipped out of sight after the murder until we caught up to him at W.T.’s Monday night.”

Matheny said McCormick had a gun and a knife in his possession, both items which belonged to the victim. The knife, authorities believe, is the knife with which Tanner allegedly cut McCormick. Matheny believes the blood found on the ground near the crime scene belongs to McCormick. Investigators have a warrant to draw blood from the suspect to see if it matches the DNA of the blood found at the crime scene.

According to McCormick’s version of events, he and Tanner got into an altercation outside the victim’s trailer at which time McCormick said Tanner cut him with a knife. Matheny said there are scars on McCormick’s hand possibly the result of a knifing.

It was during the fight McCormick said he grabbed Tanner around the neck and choked him to death. McCormick is 5-foot-10 and weighs around 210.

After killing Tanner sometime in the evening hours, McCormick reportedly left the scene, leaving the victim on the ground outside the trailer. He then returned several hours later and pulled Tanner’s body into the trailer and started the fire which burned the victim’s body.

As for motive, investigators suspect McCormick may have had intentions of robbing the victim since personal property, including an undisclosed amount of cash, was taken by McCormick.

“Our officers worked hard and were able to come up with key leads that helped solve this case relatively quickly,” Matheny said. “We’ve still got some work to do, but I’m proud of our officers and their effort.”

McCormick remains held under $500,000 bond at Warren County Jail awaiting arraignment. He has a limited prior criminal record including arrests for drugs and driving charges.

Leave a Comment