Skip to content

Lewis denied new trial: Judge Turnbull finds no reason to reduce sentence

Lewis denied new trial: Judge Turnbull finds no reason to reduce sentence

LEWIS
Johnny Lewis has been denied a new trial for his part in the Myers Lane triple murders.

The denial came Friday following a hearing before Judge John Turnbull in Livingston. The denial means Lewis’ next recourse is to take his case before the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals.

Lewis is serving a 65-year sentence following his conviction last year on a multitude of charges stemming from the triple slaying which occurred in 1999 at the Myers Lane residence of Dianne Watts, 42. The victims, including Watts, her daughter, Jessica Watts, 10, and family friend, Chelsie Smith, 13, were beaten to death at the residence by Doug Myers, 42.

Myers was convicted on murder charges earlier this year in a separate trial from Lewis and is serving several sentences of life without chance of parole. Lewis was convicted on lesser charges of facilitation of murder and aggravated arson.

Jurors believed Lewis was at the scene and set fire to the house in an attempt to destroy murder evidence. Lewis admitted to being at the house, but denied anything happened while he was there.

In appealing the conviction, Lewis’ attorney Larry Warner outlined 15 reasons he believes there are problems with the conviction and sentence. The defense questioned Lewis’ lengthy sentence since one of his prior convictions was set aside by the court of appeals. His conviction for being a habitual traffic offender was reversed by the appeals court due to lack of evidence.

However, Judge Turnbull emphasized he did not base the length of Lewis’ sentence on his prior habitual traffic offender conviction, and therefore, it was not a reason for his sentence to be reduced.

The court will next entertain a motion for a new trial from Myers, whose mother, Clementine Myers, is still waiting to be tried on murder conspiracy charges. She is presently docketed for trial this June; however, the trial could be held at a later date.

Leave a Comment