Flat tax of 17 percent the way to go
“An abomination.” That’s how Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill describes the federal tax code. Its complexity, he says, “strangles our prosperity.” It “is a drag on our ability to create jobs in this country.”
Hardly anyone – save for maybe professional tax preparers – disagrees.
The tax code weighs in at a whopping 1.4 million words (and counting), according to a report last year by the Joint Committee on Taxation, a congressional panel. Tax regulations, which help us figure out how much we owe the federal treasury, add another eight million words or so.
The $194 billion cost of complying is greater than the annual state personal income of Maine, Delaware, Rhode Island, Vermont, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wyoming. It’s like having the entire populations of those states spending every dollar they earn each year on tax compliance.
The Bush administration clearly recognizes the need for tax simplification. Yet, the president’s 10-year tax cut actually complicated matters, requiring 441 separate tax code changes.
That’s not to say that the taxpaying public is ungrateful for the $1.35 trillion in tax relief the president has given them — only that two-thirds of Americans feel that the federal tax system is far too complex.
Secretary O’Neill promises that the Treasury will produce a series of reports on the complexities of the tax code, and that his department will offer “possible solutions” and “work with Congress to see what we can implement this year.”
That’s all well and good. Maybe the White House and Congress will agree to cut 100,000 words or so from the tax code. Maybe they will eliminate a section, or five or 10.
So, instead of taking the average person 13 hours to fill out a 1040, according to the Internal Revenue Service, maybe it will take only 11 or 12 hours of their life.
And, instead of 56 percent of Americans having to rely on paid return preparers to do their taxes for them – who in all too many cases get it wrong – maybe it will be only 50 percent.
Thus, if the Bush administration truly believes the existing tax system is, in O’Neill’s words, an abomination, if it truly intends to pursue meaningful tax simplification, it must dare to be bold.
It must make the case for a flat tax.
Under such an infinitely simpler, infinitely more sensible tax system, there would no longer be five different individual income tax rates, eight different corporate rates and several hundred different deductions, credits, exemptions and exclusions for individuals and businesses.
Instead, every taxpayer above a certain annual income level, say, $34,000, would pay a flat rate of, say, 17 percent.
No more would taxpayers struggle to fill out a 1040, with its 144 intimidating pages of instructions, its 11 schedules, and 19 separate work sheets. They could file their returns on a post-card-sized tax form.
Critics of the flat tax argue that it is “regressive.” They say it is unfair to tax people at the same rate no matter their income.
But that’s not the way the taxpaying public sees it. In a 1999 Associated Press poll, more than half said that a flat tax “with the same rate for everyone” is more fair than “the system we have now,” progressive rates and all.
(Joseph Perkins is a columnist for The San Diego Union-Tribune and can be reached at [email protected].)
