Skip to content

Highway deaths drop by 101; officials credit new seat belt law

NASHVILLE — State traffic fatalities fell by 101 this year, and officials from the Governor’s Highway Safety office say a new seat belt law is part of the reason.

So far, there have been 1,090 road deaths in the state, compared with 1,191 reported in 2003.

“This is the fourth year in which fatalities have decreased,” said Chuck Taylor, director of the safety office. “It can be directly attributed to two factors: the Governor’s Highway Safety Office programs and the seat belt legislation.”

The seat belt law allowing officers to stop drivers who aren’t buckled up took effect July 1. It strengthened a law that required seat belts but didn’t let officers issue tickets unless drivers were stopped for another traffic offense. It passed the Legislature over objections by some lawmakers that it would infringe on personal rights.

Sen. Douglas Henry, D-Nashville, said Thursday that he doesn’t doubt the law has helped fatalities decrease in Tennessee, but seat belt usage is still a personal choice.

“You and I take responsibility for our own personal safety,” said Henry, who voted against the legislation. “I used seat belts before the law said you had to. It’s not the state’s responsibility to tell people they have to wear them.”

Rep. Jack Sharp, R-East Ridge, says the law was just another restriction forced on Tennesseans by the federal government, which increased the state’s share of highway construction funds when it was passed. He’s not convinced the new law is saving lives.

“People have had seat belts for more than 40 years,” Sharp said. “Some people use them. Some people don’t. The reasons we have a primary seat belt law is money.”

John White, an emergency room worker at Erlanger Medical Center in Chattanooga, disagrees. He said he knows of several accidents where people should have been ejected from their vehicles, but seat belts saved their lives.

“Seat belt usage could mean you either walk away or are flown from a wreck,” White said. “Injuries haven’t been as severe because of the use of seat belts (and) we’ve had the same amount of car wrecks (this year).”

Taylor says the safety office spends about $20 million annually. Those federal dollars help implement safety efforts like local sobriety check points and traffic stop training programs for officers. Millions go toward the office’s “Click It or Ticket” seat belt promotion and “Booze It and Lose It” anti-DUI campaign at sporting events like Titans and Grizzlies games.

“It’s true we have a hard hill to climb because we are competing with beer marketing,” Taylor said. “But we get our message out.”

The office also distributes grants to regional jurisdictions and small communities to help purchase equipment for traffic stops and pay prosecutors in DUI cases.

“We feel that we are providing a holistic approach in educating the public and assisting law enforcement to solve this problem,” Taylor said.

Taylor said there’s another sign his office’s efforts are paying off. Seat belt use has jumped from 68.5 percent in 2003 to 72 percent in 2004.

Leave a Comment