We deserve the best from our military and the media
TO THE EDITOR:
The current controversy concerning the alleged shooting and killing of one or more captured insurgents by one or more U.S. Marines in Iraq is a stark reminder of the horrors of war and of the traditional tension between the military and the media.
This tension stems from the disparate roles of the military and the media in our society. The core mission of the military is to serve as an instrument of national security – to fight and win our wars. The role of the media is to inform us about how well the military is accomplishing its mission including the good, bad and ugly. If the military does its job and the media do theirs, the public interest is served.
Predictably, the “fog of war” creates ambiguity, particularly in the crucible of combat. It is this ambiguity that leads to different versions of the truth, and to potential love-hate relationships between the military and the media. To their credit, both of these vital institutions in our society have sought common ground on ways to clarify this ambiguity, and to inform the public without compromising national security or endangering the troops.
The process of “embedding” reporters with the troops in Afghanistan and Iraq is a graphic example of the progress we have made. As a former combat infantryman, I view it as a huge, though imperfect step toward reaching the necessary common ground between the military and the media.
Unfortunately, embedding is not under attack, not from the military and not from the media, but curiously, from some members of Congress. Meanwhile, military leaders, including the Commandant of the Marine Corps, defend embedding. So do many of the media, including Walter Rodgers, a distinguished CNN war correspondent.
I disagree with those who attack embedding and stand with those who defend it. When the military and the media perform their respective roles with dedication, we have little to fear from either. As citizens of the USA, we deserve and should demand the best from both.
Sincerely,
Thomas B. Vaughn
Colonel, U.S. Army, Retired
212 Morrison Street
