Skip to content

Did first man arrive in North America sooner than scientists believe? New study indicates date may have been long before Ice Age

When was the first man on this continent?

For years, scientists have held the belief that man first arrived about 13,000 years ago when migrants crossed the Bering Strait during the Ice Age into modern-day Alaska but were unable to move further south because of ice-sheets covering what is now Canada.

But a handful of archaeological sites — including the Topper Site in Allendale County — are raising questions about that date. Could man have arrived here sooner?

University of South Carolina archaeologist Al Goodyear has released radiocarbon dating results on plant remains found deep at the Topper dig site. The results show the remains are at least 50,000 years old.

The finding is significant because it means humans could have inhabited North America long before the last ice age more than 20,000 years ago.

The discovery began in South Carolina in 1981 when Goodyear was surveying a local flint called chert in Allendale County near the Savannah River. A local man named Topper directed him to a prehistoric quarry that became known as the Topper Site.

In the mid-1980s, Goodyear and his team found signs of the mammoth-hunting Clovis people. Scientists found large chert tools dating back 13,000 years about three feet below the surface.

Goodyear didn’t think of going further into the ground because the prevailing theory was that there was nothing earlier than Clovis.

A few years later, Goodyear became intrigued by controversial pre-Clovis findings in Monteverde, Chile, and Cactus Hill, Va. So in 1998, Goodyear decided to dig deeper.

If there were pre-Clovis people, Goodyear reasoned, the area would be a good place to live. They would be near the Savannah River, which flows from the mountains to the ocean. And the area would be free of the glaciers that extended into North America during the Ice Age.

As Goodyear’s team dug deeper — some 11 feet down — they found a number of artifacts similar to the pre-Clovis tools excavated in that area.

Then, on the last day of digging, Goodyear said they made an exciting discovery. They found a black substance that appeared to be charcoal. He speculated it could have been some kind of hearth.

Thomas Stafford, director of Stafford Laboratories in Boulder, Colo., and a visiting professor at the University of Wisconsin, took samples of the substance. They were sent to the University of California at Irvine for testing.

The results showed plant material — oak, pine, red cherry and buckeye — that had been burned in a low-temperature fire, Stafford said. Testing dated them at least 50,300 years, he said.

The findings help to undermine the Bering Strait theory, said Vine Deloria, an author and retired University of Colorado history professor.

“Indians have been waiting for this kind of discovery for centuries, ever since the infantile and nonsensical Bering Strait theory became possible,” Deloria said. “If more attention were paid to tribal traditions, science could learn a lot more and much faster than their snail’s pace one-site-at-a-time practices.”

While it’s not time to rewrite the science books, the findings do raise questions about current scientific theories, said Eric Powell, managing editor of Archaeology magazine.

“Just how rapidly did we humans colonize the world? And how did they get here?” Powell asked.

Leave a Comment