Skip to content

Peterson must now fight to save his life: Experts believe he could have guilty verdict overturned

The jury that convicted Scott Peterson saw a man with two faces: in public, a loving father-to-be with a steady job and stable home, and in private a cheating husband who yearned for bachelorhood and was willing to kill for it.

Convicted Friday of murdering his pregnant wife and her fetus, Peterson must now present a unified image on two fronts — he must convince jurors that his life is worth sparing while arguing to the courts that he was wrongly convicted.

Some experts said he might have a chance to win an appeal, given the dismissal of two jurors during deliberations. After his sentencing, defense investigators are likely to interview panelists, looking for any signs of misconduct.

“These jurors are about to go under the microscope,” said Loyola Law School professor Laurie Levenson.

Peterson faces life in prison or the death penalty for the first-degree murder of his wife, Laci, and second-degree murder of the fetus.

While the first part of the trial focused on evidence, the penalty phase, beginning Nov. 22, will be laced with raw emotion.

Blockbuster testimony is expected from Laci Peterson’s mother, Sharon Rocha, who will testify about losing a 27-year-old daughter and the grandson she was waiting for.

“She’s going to get up there and she’s going to break down. Her voice is going to crack,” said Daniel Horowitz, a criminal defense attorney and regular trial observer.

Peterson is unlikely to take the stand and beg for mercy. Instead, testimony will likely include pleas from his parents to spare his life.

Jury consultant Ed Bronson said Peterson’s defense attorney, Mark Geragos, will try to tap any lingering doubt over whether Peterson was a calculated killer. The defense is expected to remind jurors that the 32-year-old former fertilizer salesman has no criminal record or history of violence.

Leave a Comment