Skip to content

Police claim Simmons tried to burn sister’s home

The man who shot the sheriff is in trouble again, this time for trying to torch his sister’s home while she and her husband were inside.

The suspect, Barry P. Simmons, 45, is charged with aggravated assault and attempted aggravated arson for a night of dangerous actions – which included pulling a gun on his brother-in-law and dousing the home in gasoline.

According to Sheriff Jackie Matheny, who Simmons shot nearly 18 years ago, the incident began when Simmons, who had been drinking, got mad at his brother-in-law. Simmons, who is on parole, was staying at their home at the time.

Simmons reportedly then pulled a gun on his brother-in-law, threatening to shoot him. However, the man was able to take the gun away from Simmons. It was later when Simmons was caught by his brother-in-law, dousing the house in gasoline in an apparent attempt to torch the house with his sister and brother-in-law inside.

The arrest of Simmons for the attempted arson comes after he served about 10 years of a 32-year sentence he received for shooting then-rookie police officer Jackie Matheny in 1986. On that evening, Matheny pursued Simmons into a residence on Black Street and was shot in the arm by Simmons with a .22 rifle.

The recent arrest is not Simmons’ first brush with the law since being released. He was arrested in early 2001 for trying to pull over a woman near Morrison while posing as a police officer.

Leave a Comment