Dickson fortuneteller wins federal lawsuit against city
U.S. District Court Judge Robert Echols ruled in favor of fortuneteller Beth Daly of Dickson and the American Civil Liberties Union.
“I’m very satisfied, very pleased,” Daly said Tuesday. “The Constitution of the United States was written for freedom of speech, freedom of expression, freedom of religion. I think people should be able to express themselves and believe how they want without having other people try to control them.”
Tom Waychoff, city administrator for Dickson, said the city’s lawyer was out of the country and that no decision on whether to appeal will be made until he returns.
“It’ll really be the decision of the city council, if they feel like they should continue with the case after consulting with the city lawyer, they’ll appeal,” he said.
Daly said she would continue to fight, even though she has no plans to reopen The Curiosity Corner, a shop where she sold books, art, candles, yoga supplies, glassware and told customers their fortunes for a $25 fee.
Within a month of opening the shop two years ago, Daly was told by Waychoff that city ordinance banned her from telling fortunes for a fee, court records show. Waychoff told her she could continue fortune telling for free.
Daly said she had made up to $600 a month telling fortunes but decided to stop charging.
“She shut her business down in order to obey the law, but at the same time the government was violating her free speech rights,” said ACLU executive director Hedy Weinberg.
The ACLU sued the city in 2003 and Dickson replaced the ban with a new law requiring fortunetellers to post a written notice on premises and in any advertisements that said Tennessee has no requirements governing “the education, training or ability of fortunetellers, clairvoyants, palmists, phrenologists or other person claiming to be mystics endowed with supernatural powers.”
The disclaimer also was to state that it is a crime for any business to engage in deceptive practices.
The ACLU and Daly contended the posting requirement to be a violation of free speech, while the city said it was intended to protect citizens from fraud.
Echols rejected the city’s argument, saying it was an overly broad restriction that was based on the content of the speech.
Echols cited earlier rulings that found “predictions are only fraudulent if the speaker knows of facts that will prevent a prediction from coming true.”
Weinberg said the ruling is a “victory for free speech rights. It ensures people are free to express their opinions — and make predictions — without government interference.”
Daly said publicity over the case stirred discussion of witchery and forced her out of business because customers grew afraid to come to the shop.
She now is studying to be a paralegal and a private investigator.
“I want to help people so they don’t have to go through what I went through,” Daly said. “For two years I’ve been fighting something I shouldn’t have had to fight.”
