State Supreme Court to hear case involving Knoxville video store
In an opinion last year, the state Court of Appeals deemed unconstitutional a Knoxville ordinance that barred adult businesses from locating within 1,000 feet of neighborhoods, establishments that sell alcohol and public recreation facilities.
The decision was a victory for Nashville-based Entertainment Resources LLC., which had battled to keep its Fantasy Video store open. The business closed in 2001 after it was cited 53 times for violating the ordinance during a strong enforcement campaign.
Attorneys for Entertainment Resources argued the ordinance’s language was too vague. The ordinance defined an adult business as one in which “a substantial or significant portion” of its inventory was devoted to adult entertainment.
The store offered thousands of sexually explicit tapes for rent in a back room, and stocked the front portion of the business with movies ranging from G- to R-rated. Attorneys contended the store carried more general-interest titles than X-rated movies.
The city argued the tamer films were only window dressing.
In 1998, Knox County Chancellor Daryl Fansler sided with the city and approved a temporary injunction that barred Fantasy Video from operating unless the business either moved or reduced its adult offerings.
The store lost its lease in January 2001. Four months later, Fansler declared the legal battle over. The appellate court disagreed, saying the ordinance was unconstitutional and Entertainment Resources could be entitled to damages.
———
Information from: The Knoxville News Sentinel, http://www.knoxnews.com
