Skip to content

Armchair Quarterback: Eli the No. 1 choice for Chargers

Okay, it’s April 24 and you’re in the San Diego Chargers front office. What do you do?

You’ve come off a very disappointing 4-12 season, firmly earning you the right to pick first in the NFL draft. Your franchise quarterback, Drew Brees, has been a bust, replaced during last season by Doug Flutie who is old enough to have grandchildren. Your line is one of the worst in the league, giving your quarterback little or no time to get rid of the ball. Oh, by the way, your gamble for big-time wideout David Boston was a bust and he’s hauling in passes for the Dolphins this coming season. Tick, tock, tick, tock. What do you do?

Come on folks. Unless the Chargers can get a deal like the one that got Mike Ditka fired as Saints coach a few years ago (that being trading away all draft picks for Texas runningback Ricky Williams) then this is a no-brainer. Um, San Diego, Eli Manning is on the board.

Right now, with the draft about three weeks away, there’s a lot of chatter coming out of the Charger camp as they field the phone calls like they’re working a telethon. They are saying they are willing to entertain all offers for the coveted number-one pick. This, in itself is a good thing. However, their public consideration of taking University of Iowa tackle Robert Gallery over Manning would be a monumental mistake. Either you get a king’s ransom for the first pick or you take Manning.

Look at the history of his name-sake. Peyton Manning is Co-MVP and is probably, barring injury, going to go down as one of the best quarterbacks in league history. If he plays out a career with the Colts his name will be right beside Unitas on the wall of fame. His younger brother Eli is from the same mold, perhaps even a tick better since he played at Ole Miss and wasn’t surrounded by top-notch receivers like his brother was at Tennessee, also sometimes called Wide Receiver U.

If the Chargers for unknown reasons do not take Manning and don’t trade down, he could actually slip significantly down the board as the Raiders, with the second pick, say they are happy with Rich Gannon, who is recovering from his injury of last year. At three, the Cards say they will stay with Josh McCown, the same guy who threw the pass that took the Vikings out of the playoffs last year. The Giants could be the next possibility at four, but they do have Kerry Collins, who isn’t half bad. At five the Skins now have Brunnell and at six the Lions already have Joey Herrington who is doing well. All that would happen if the Chargers pass on Manning is someone else will use their pick as trade fodder.

A consideration is also a sleeper in Miami of Ohio quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, even though fitting that name on the back of a shirt could be a challenge. The scouts say Manning and Roethlisberger are very similar as far as ability. Of course, that’s what they said about Peyton Manning and Ryan Leaf too.

If I’m in the Charger front office I invoke the spirit of Dan Fouts (not actually dead yet) and draft Manning at one. Then, the draft becomes simple. The Raiders take Pitt receiver Larry Fitzgerald or Miami safety Sean Taylor at two with the Cards taking the one of those that slips to three, that is, unless they want to take a whack at Roy Williams out of Texas at wideout. Look for that “soldier” Kellen Winslow Jr. to go early, possibly even to the Skins, who are already wealthy in talent and coaches.

Sure, it’d be nostalgic for Winslow to play in San Diego where his father played, but he’s of no use to a team who has no one to get him the ball. Unless there’s just a honey of a deal on the table, the Chargers have got to take Manning.

Leave a Comment