Media Musings: Media consolidation is bad news


The latest news about America journalism isn’t good. It’s not good especially for broadcast television networks and newspapers and it’s even worse for the republic which has gambled its all on an informed people.
And here is the irony of it: The quality of newspaper ethics is the best in our history. Take note of how aggressively and passionately The New York Times and USA Today have pursued two gifted rogue reporters who fabricated parts of stories they wrote over the years. The Times fired its top editors (they resigned, wink, wink) and USA Today, which just published the findings of its investigation, will undoubtedly make serious changes in both leadership and editing procedures.
Here are some major findings from the Project for Excellence in Journalism, a research institute associated with the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, funded by Pew Charitable Trusts:
• Circulation of English-language newspapers has dropped 11 percent in 14 years.
• Circulation of Spanish-language daily newspapers has tripled to 1.7 million.
• Circulation of alternative weeklies like The Nashville Scene has more than doubled to 7.5 million.
• The combined audience of the three major cable news channels has not grown since 2001 (Fox News disputed the finding).
Why, you ask? Here are some brutal findings, and it’s not because you don’t have the time to read or watch network news:
• There are 2,200 fewer employees at newspapers today than in 1990.
• The number of network correspondents has dropped 30 percent in the last 25 years and half of the foreign bureaus are shuttered.
• Forty-four percent of radio news reporters were cut between 1994 and 2001.
Good news, too, though:
• National Public Radio, which Congress neo-cons want to defund all of the time, has seen its audience double in the last 10 years.
• National newscasts carry more stories about government and politics than they did 12 years ago but still don’t match the 1970s.
There are some obvious, deeper reasons for this situation.
It can be laid at the feet of Congress, which, led by President Clinton and Vice President Gore, agreed in 1996 to ending any meaningful limits on the number of radio stations one company can own (Clear Channel now has more than 1,200). So, Clear Channel goes into a major market, has five stations, fires the news staffs at four of them, and saves a bundle. Bye bye, competition.
And, as the numbers of evening newspapers began to die, the remaining “properties” became so valuable that the rise of newspaper chains to a level we had never seen became a dominant national force.
Hang on: according to the report, 22 companies now control 70 percent of the newspaper circulation in this nation.
Wait, you say. Why look how divided we are, and more and more so every day, and we have Fox News and CNN. Doesn’t that show we have plenty of news? No, you have shouting and yelling and reporter/celebrities. You have news bites, not meals.
But, then there’s the Internet, right? Yes, half of the 20 top news sites are owned by media companies. And the Internet is like fire: it can illuminate and give us a great quality of life and it can destroy us.
The fewer and fewer independent sources of news come at the worst of times. When we need the best and most honest information, the resources have been consumed by the bottom line in far too many cases.
There’s satellite TV and cable TV and the Internet, to be sure. Perhaps they can grow ever more diverse. In so doing, they would keep alive our ability to make educated choices in a world forevermore changed by 9/11. Keep hope alive.
(Ed Kimbrell is a professor in MTSU’s School of Journalism.)
