Skip to content

Bredesen hopes to outlaw ‘Toughman’ events

NASHVILLE (AP) — Gov. Phil Bredesen’s administration is pushing to abolish “Toughman” competitions and similar fighting events in Tennessee, saying they are too dangerous to participants.

“The administration came to the conclusion that this is an activity basically sanctioning a night spot, or whatever, holding contests where untrained, unconditioned, nonprofessional people beat the stuffing out of each other,” said Paula Wade, spokeswoman for the Department of Commerce and Insurance.

But the operator of “Rough and Rowdy Brawl” events in Tennessee and four other states said the sport is safer and more interesting to spectators than professional and amateur boxing.

“In 82 years, we’ve put on nearly 100 of these events with about 100 contestants a show — close to 10,000 contestants — and we’ve never had a death or any serious injuries,” Christopher M. Smith of Charleston, W.Va., told The Knoxville News Sentinel. “Maybe a few separated shoulders, cracked ribs and busted noses.”

Contestants are paired by weight and age for the bouts, which sometimes come in a series of three or four on a single night to determine who wins prizes. A “Rough and Rowdy Brawl” event was held in Knoxville last month, drawing about 2,500 patrons during two days.

Another event is scheduled in Chattanooga next month.

Smith said most opposition to his events comes from the Golden Gloves organizations and professional boxers, who see the contests as competition.

At least 13 people have died in the United States since 1979 fighting in such events, according to Don Meyers, who began a national crusade to prohibit Toughman competitions after his sister-in-law, Stacy Young, died in September following a Sarasota, Fla., “Toughwoman” match. At least four people have died in the competitions during the last two years.

Meyers said 20 states have basically stopped the contests.

Last week, the Washington state legislature sent a bill to its governor outlawing certain kinds of no-holds-barred amateur fighting, including Toughman competitions. The bill made promotions of such contests a felony.

Toughman is the trademark of an organization that was a pioneer in launching amateur fighting competitions.

A statute enacted in 1990 specifically permits the events in Tennessee. The Department of Commerce and Insurance has proposed repealing the statute, with the bill scheduled for a vote in the Senate Commerce Committee on Tuesday.

“We’re almost kidding ourselves to think we’re regulating it,” said Robert Gowan, assistant commissioner of the commerce department in charge of regulatory boards. “The whole nature of those events is to get people who are inexperienced. It’s the opposite of real boxing. Literally, you can show up that night and get in the ring, whether you should be getting into it or not.”

State officials normally have the option of revoking a person’s license if they violate a law or rule, Gowan said. That’s not the case with Toughman events because they are not licensed, he said.

Smith said some event promoters may not take the precautions that “Rough and Rowdy Brawls” does, including “safety head gear, groin protectors and skilled referees” with two doctors on site. Without the precautions, he said, the sport can be dangerous.

———

On the Net:

Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance: http://www.state.tn.us/commerce/

Rough and Ready Brawl: www.boxingcontest.com.

Toughman organization: www.toughmancontest.com

Leave a Comment