Voice of Reason: Gay marriage the least of our worries
American society has no lack of problems. Terrorism, meth and other hard drugs, gun violence, domestic violence, rape, assault, murder, sexual abuse, child pornography ? these are but a few of the problems we face. Love and marriage, however, are not problems.
Love and marriage, of the homosexual variety, came under attack in November when the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruled same and opposite sex couples must be given equal marriage rights under the state’s constitution. Listening to the evangelical set, one would assume non-heterosexual marriage is the biggest threat to America since the Cuban Missile Crisis.
As a result of the “travesty” that is gay marriage, the religious rights leaders in Congress and the White House has mobilized to “save” marriage, going so far as to sponsor a constitutional amendment which would sanction marriage as a union between a man and a woman only. This is monumental step is necessary, they say, to preserve marriage as the bedrock of civilization and to stop “activist” courts from bypassing the wishes of the people and their elected representatives.
(On a side note, the bemoaning of “activist” courts is amusing, as if judging the constitutionality of laws is not the purpose of the courts. It must be remembered that if not for an “activist” court in 1954, segregation might still be the law of the land here in the South.)
Those who say that marriage is the bedrock of civilization are right. The institution of marriage serves to cement society together as it promotes monogamy, security and stable homes and families. This is exactly why it needs to be extended to all Americans, including homosexuals. The more secure and stable all relationships and families are, the better off we, as a society, will be.
The argument that gay marriage would somehow undermine straight marriage is absurd. If an institution such as straight marriage is so flimsy that it can be shaken by the love and devotion of same-sex couples who are not bothering anyone, not committing any crimes, than perhaps it is not even worth defending in the first place. It seems to me that anyone who has a strong marriage has nothing to fear from two other people, no matter what their sex, loving each other and showing their own commitment to each other by taking marriage vows.
Indeed, if lawmakers really want to preserve the “sanctity” of marriage (which for millennia was more about finances and politics than love and devotion), a much more effective action would be to make divorce and adultery illegal. Something tells me, however, this would never even be considered.
Truth be told, banning gay marriage could do more harm than good for those who favor the strengthening of the institution of marriage. Under the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment, only gay marriage would be banned. It would do nothing to prevent states from enacting civil unions for gays. These union, which fall short of full marriage, still allow homosexuals such rights as next-of-kin status, inheritance and insurance rights and the ability to file jointly on state tax returns.
As civil unions between gays become more and more prevalent, eventually heterosexual couples will be demanding the same rights. They too will want to be able to attain civil union status, looking for a less significant first step, or perhaps alternative, to full marriage. This, in turn, will lead to a decrease in the number of families united by the institution of marriage, which is exactly what many evangelicals are arguing against!
Wouldn’t that be ironic?
(Will Stewart is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].)
