The role of religion in politics
Howard Dean is right to recognize the power of faith in public life, and talk to voters about his own beliefs. The question is whether he sounds sincere on the subject. So far, he’s not been very convincing.
As one joke puts it, Dean had a conversion on “the road to Columbia,” the capital of South Carolina, a state that will hold a critical primary Feb. 3. A man who speaks so eloquently on the subject of war has not found his voice on the subject of faith. Most of what he says sounds canned and calculated, not candid or committed. And that’s no way to win votes.
Americans have always felt strongly about religion in politics, but they’ve always set limits as well. The founding fathers firmly rejected the idea of a religious “test” for public officeholders, and that principle still holds true today. Yet a recent Pew Research Center poll reports that 7 of 10 voters want their president to be a “person of faith.”
Is there a contradiction here? Not really. In such a diverse country, with no official religion, faith is primarily a question of values, not doctrine.
Americans don’t like candidates who are so prideful in their religious beliefs that they would impose them on others. They want leaders who combine two virtues: devotion and tolerance.
The Rev. Pat Robertson, for example, was a deeply religious man but a poor presidential candidate, partly because he had no use for people who disagreed with him.
But if religious faith does not guarantee success, as in Robertson’s case, it can be a very useful political asset. Consider this: the only two Democrats to win the White House in 36 years, Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton, were both Southern Baptists fluent in the language of faith and scripture.
Or look at the two Bushes. George the elder is like Howard Dean, a New England preppie by birth and training. He moved to the Bible Belt but never fully acquired the religious rhythms of his new home, and that helped make him vulnerable to Clinton’s challenge.
George the younger more closely resembles Clinton than his own father in this regard. He’s a true Texan, comfortable with faith-based politics.
It’s important for any Democratic candidate to speak credibly on the subject of religion because Republicans have done such an effective job of stealing the issue.
A recent Zogby poll reports that, among voters who attend a religious service weekly, 52 percent live in the “red” states won by Bush and only 34 percent live in the “blue” states won by Al Gore. A Pew study shows that 58 percent of Americans regard the Republican Party as friendly toward religion, but only 41 percent describe the Democrats that way.
One candidate who understands this faith gap is Sen. Joe Lieberman, a devout Jew, who said this about religion: “The important point is we’ve got to talk about it. Otherwise the Republicans will get away with convincing people that they have some kind of monopoly on values and faith. In fact, they don’t.”
So how does a stiff, tight-lipped New Englander find his voice on the issue of religion? Can he close the faith gap? Only by being himself, not someone else. Only by being sincere, not scripted. If religion is a metaphor for character, the worst thing to be is a hypocrite.
(Cokie and Steven Roberts are syndicated columnists.)
