Skip to content

Voice of Reason: Saddam’s capture no proof of our safety

Of all of the media commentary following the capture of Saddam Hussein, I think Rob Corddry of news satire program, “The Daily Show with Jon Stewart,” said it best when he commented, “After months of searching we have finally found the man who had nothing to do with September 11.”

Now don’t get me wrong, I’m just as pleased as anyone that such a murderous tyrant is no longer in power — the world is definitely a better place because of it. But to believe Saddam’s capture will make Americans any safer from al-Qaida, our true enemy, is to live in a fool’s paradise.

The fact of the matter is that, despite the allegations and insinuations of the Bush administration, there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest Saddam had anything to do with 9-11. Let me repeat this: THERE IS NO EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER TO SUGGEST SADDAM HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH 9-11.

This is obvious to anyone who forms his or her opinions based on some semblance of fact. But unfortunately, the vast majority of people get their information not from a serious study of the news, but rather from quickly scanning headlines or listening to 10-second sound bites on CNN.

Case in point is a recent USA Today poll which found that over half of all Americans — 53 percent to be exact — believe that Saddam Hussein was involved in the terrorist attacks of September 11. This isn’t surprising of course – people in general and Americans in particular are woefully ignorant and apathetic — but it is disturbing.

In discussing Saddam’s alleged 9-11 involvement with a friend, who incidentally is among the above-mentioned 53 percent, he challenged me to prove Saddam did not have anything to do with the attacks. Saddam hates America (motive) and had scads of oil money (opportunity), he said. It stands to reason, he continued, that Saddam was somehow involved, if only financially, with 9-11.

So could I prove to my friend Saddam didn’t have anything to do with the attacks? Of course not, just as I can’t prove God doesn’t exist. It’s impossible to prove a negative. And I shouldn’t have to. The burden of proof in this case in on the government – they’re the ones making the accusations. If we’re going to use the motive and opportunity argument, the case for war could be made against half the countries and despots, and countless individuals, in the world.

In making the case for the Iraq war, the Bushies used two main arguments: Saddam’s possession and willingness to use WMDs and his involvement of in 9-11, allegations which have yet to be proved true or anywhere near true. In nearly every other war or conflict of choice, the leaders of this country have offered proof to back up their claims of danger to the U.S.: Teddy Roosevelt had the (controversial) sinking of the U.S.S. Spain in Havana harbor, Kennedy had pictures of Soviet missiles off the Cuban coast and Johnson had the bombing of the U.S.S. Tonkin in Vietnam. Bush had, and has, nothing.

If the administration wanted to make a convincing case against Saddam, they could have easily used the well documented cases of the dictator’s gassing of the Kurds or his torture chambers and the mass killings of his own people to justify (or rationalize) war. Why did they choose to speculate instead?

Probably because they could, because they knew the American public (and media) would line up behind them in the name of patriotism and national security and not question given reasons too much.

They also knew that, to quote Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels, “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it people will eventually come to believe it.”

Leave a Comment