Skip to content

Shields questions legality of city noise ordinance

Saying the city’s noise ordinance is unfair and discriminatory, a local audio specialist is urging motorists who receive tickets for loud car stereos to fight the tickets in court and question their legality.

“The city’s noise ordinance is discriminatory at the very least and it’s aimed at one group of individuals,” said John Shields, electronic specialist with Amplified Audio. “If a person gets a ticket under the ordinance, I recommend they go to court and plead not guilty and challenge the law as being discriminatory.”

Shields’ comments come after the city announced a crackdown on loud stereo systems under the city’s noise ordinance.

Officers have already written more noise tickets in the past month than were written most of last year. The crackdown comes following numerous complaints by citizens concerning loud car stereos. Violation of the noise ordinance can result in a $103 ticket.

The ordinance gives officers the ability to write tickets if they feel a system is disturbing to the public. Between the hours of 11 p.m. and 7 a.m., a stereo or any device is technically not supposed to be heard from over 50 feet away.

“This is so subjective,” Shields said. “A law enforcement officer isn’t qualified to measure how loud a sound is without the proper instrumentation. There’s a lot of things you can hear from over 50 feet away, so why are we just enforcing car stereos?”

Specifically, Shields pointed to ball parks where he can hear noise much of the evening from half a mile away. Shields said other loud sounds include the church bells at Westwood and tractor pulls at the fairgrounds, all of which make more noise than the average car stereo.

“What’s happened is someone complained about a loud car stereo and then it started rolling downhill and the motorists were the target,” Shields said. “My problem with this whole thing is that they’re singling out one group for noise. Plus, and I’m not saying this is happening, but the law is open for abuse since it’s left in the hands of individual officers who have no instrumentation to measure sound.”

As a measuring stick, Shields, who has been in the audio business for 20 years, said the average car stereo puts out about 100 to 110 decibels. By comparison, a lawnmower puts out about 100, while an average conversation puts out around 65 decibels. A gunshot is around 150 decibels.

If the ordinance is to be fairly enforced, Shields said it should be even-handed, and a quantitative measurement system should be put into place. Shields said a decibel limit should be decided on and officers should be given measuring equipment to measure the decibels put out from 50 feet away.

“It’s like an officer writing you a ticket without using radar,” Shields said. “It happens all the time, but there’s no exact way for them to determine you were actually speeding or how fast you were going. If they use a decibel meter to measure the sound, then the proof is right there, according to what they want to place the limit at.”

Shields said he plans to get with his county commissioner, who also represents citizens inside the city, in hopes of modifying the noise law.

“We tell our customers to be respectful of others,” Shields said. “But, at the same time, if they do get a ticket, I’m advising them to go to court and fight it. Am I saying to shut down the ballparks and the church bells? No. I’m just saying we need to be even handed when it comes to enforcing the ordinance.”

Leave a Comment